Saddawi-Konefka Daniel, Baker Keith, Guarino Anthony, Burns Sara M, Oettingen Gabriele, Gollwitzer Peter M, Charnin Jonathan E
J Grad Med Educ. 2017 Aug;9(4):451-457. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-16-00703.1.
Following through on one's goals to study is essential for effective, self-regulated learning. This can be difficult for residents because of clinical demands and limited personal time. WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan) is a self-regulation strategy, also known as . WOOP increases follow-through on goals in many domains, although it has not, to our knowledge, been evaluated in medical education.
We compared the effect of WOOP versus goal setting on time residents spent studying.
Through a prospective, randomized, comparative effectiveness study, during a 1-month, intensive care unit rotation, we clustered anesthesiology residents in single-blind fashion to WOOP versus goal setting. Both groups received organized study materials. The intervention group performed WOOP to study more; the comparison group set goals to study more. Residents tracked studying with daily diaries. The primary outcome was total time spent studying toward stated goals. Time spent studying "non-goal" medical material was a secondary outcome.
Of 34 eligible residents, 100% participated. Sixteen residents were randomized to the WOOP group and 18 to the goal-setting group. The WOOP group spent significantly more time studying toward their goals compared with the goal-setting group (median = 4.3 hours versus 1.5 hours; = .021; = 0.66). There was no significant difference in time spent studying non-goal medical material between groups (median = 5.5 hours versus 5.0 hours, = .99).
WOOP increased the time residents spent studying toward their goals as compared with setting goals alone.
坚持完成学习目标对于有效的自主学习至关重要。由于临床工作需求和个人时间有限,这对住院医师来说可能具有挑战性。WOOP(愿望、结果、障碍、计划)是一种自我调节策略,也被称为……。尽管据我们所知,WOOP尚未在医学教育中得到评估,但它在许多领域都能提高目标的坚持性。
我们比较了WOOP与设定目标对住院医师学习时间的影响。
通过一项前瞻性、随机、比较有效性研究,在为期1个月的重症监护病房轮转期间,我们以单盲方式将麻醉科住院医师分为WOOP组和设定目标组。两组都收到了有组织的学习材料。干预组运用WOOP来增加学习;对照组设定更多学习目标。住院医师通过每日日记记录学习情况。主要结局是朝着既定目标学习所花费的总时间。学习“非目标”医学材料所花费的时间是次要结局。
34名符合条件的住院医师全部参与。16名住院医师被随机分配到WOOP组,18名被分配到设定目标组。与设定目标组相比,WOOP组朝着目标学习花费的时间显著更多(中位数=4.3小时对1.5小时;P=0.021;效应量=0.66)。两组在学习非目标医学材料上花费的时间没有显著差异(中位数=5.5小时对5.0小时,P=0.99)。
与仅设定目标相比,WOOP增加了住院医师朝着目标学习的时间。