Gutberg Jennifer, Berta Whitney
Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, 155 College Street, Toronto, ON, M5T 3M6, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Aug 22;17(1):582. doi: 10.1186/s12913-017-2533-4.
The past fifteen years have been marked by large-scale change efforts undertaken by healthcare organizations to improve patient safety and patient-centered care. Despite substantial investment of effort and resources, many of these large-scale or "radical change" initiatives, like those in other industries, have enjoyed limited success - with practice and behavioural changes neither fully adopted nor ultimately sustained - which has in large part been ascribed to inadequate implementation efforts. Culture change to "patient safety culture" (PSC) is among these radical change initiatives, where results to date have been mixed at best.
This paper responds to calls for research that focus on explicating factors that affect efforts to implement radical change in healthcare contexts, and focuses on PSC as the radical change implementation. Specifically, this paper offers a novel conceptual model based on Organizational Learning Theory to explain the ability of middle managers in healthcare organizations to influence patient safety culture change. We propose that middle managers can capitalize on their unique position between upper and lower levels in the organization and engage in 'ambidextrous' learning that is critical to implementing and sustaining radical change. This organizational learning perspective offers an innovative way of framing the mid-level managers' role, through both explorative and exploitative activities, which further considers the necessary organizational context in which they operate.
在过去的十五年里,医疗保健机构为改善患者安全和以患者为中心的护理进行了大规模的变革努力。尽管投入了大量的精力和资源,但许多这样的大规模或“激进变革”举措,与其他行业的举措一样,取得的成功有限——实践和行为改变既未得到充分采用,也未最终持续下去——这在很大程度上归因于实施力度不足。向“患者安全文化”(PSC)的文化变革就是这些激进变革举措之一,迄今为止其结果充其量是喜忧参半。
本文回应了聚焦于阐释影响医疗保健环境中激进变革实施因素研究的呼吁,并将PSC作为激进变革实施的重点。具体而言,本文基于组织学习理论提供了一个新颖的概念模型来解释医疗保健机构中层管理人员影响患者安全文化变革的能力。我们认为,中层管理人员可以利用他们在组织中处于高层和低层之间的独特地位,并进行对实施和维持激进变革至关重要的“双元”学习。这种组织学习视角通过探索性和利用性活动,为界定中层管理人员的角色提供了一种创新方式,还进一步考虑了他们运作所需的组织背景。