Quinn Brenna L, Fantasia Heidi Collins
School of Nursing, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, Massachusetts.
School of Nursing, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, Massachusetts.
Pain Manag Nurs. 2018 Jun;19(3):303-312. doi: 10.1016/j.pmn.2017.07.002. Epub 2017 Aug 24.
Within current priorities for pain research set by the American Society for Pain Management Nursing, there is a paucity of pediatric pain research. Qualitative approaches are helpful when researching topics about which little is known. Focus groups are one method of qualitative data collection and have been successfully implemented with children and parents.
The purpose of this paper was to identify ideal conditions for nurse researchers to employ when using focus groups as a data collection method for studies aiming to investigate pain in children. The aims of this paper are to identify focus group conditions (1) facilitating adequate scientific rigor and trustworthiness and (2) eliciting the richest data from participants.
A critique of research studies that used focus groups with children, parents/caregivers, or nurses in hospital or community settings was performed to achieve the stated aims. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines directed the process of selecting studies for inclusion in this review.
The final sample for critique included four studies. Methods such as transcription processes and approaches to analysis used in the four publications were appraised for scientific rigor and usefulness in pediatric pain research.
Researchers investigating priority areas must consider trustworthiness and strategies to eliciting quality data when planning to employ focus groups as a data collection method. Nurses in the clinical setting can use findings of this report to strengthen pain assessment practices as well as evaluate qualitative work for inclusion in evidence-based policies.
在美国疼痛管理护理学会设定的当前疼痛研究重点中,儿科疼痛研究匮乏。当研究鲜为人知的主题时,定性研究方法很有帮助。焦点小组是定性数据收集的一种方法,已成功应用于儿童和家长群体。
本文旨在确定护士研究人员在将焦点小组作为旨在调查儿童疼痛的研究的数据收集方法时应采用的理想条件。本文的目的是确定焦点小组条件:(1)促进足够的科学严谨性和可信度;(2)从参与者那里获取最丰富的数据。
对在医院或社区环境中与儿童、家长/照顾者或护士使用焦点小组的研究进行了批判性分析,以实现既定目标。系统评价和荟萃分析的首选报告项目指南指导了选择纳入本评价的研究的过程。
最终用于批判性分析的样本包括四项研究。对这四篇出版物中使用的转录过程和分析方法等进行了科学严谨性和在儿科疼痛研究中的实用性评估。
在计划将焦点小组作为数据收集方法时,研究优先领域的研究人员必须考虑可信度和获取高质量数据的策略。临床环境中的护士可以利用本报告的结果来加强疼痛评估实践,并评估定性研究工作以纳入循证政策。