Rubini Lauretta, Pollio Chiara, Di Tommaso Marco R
Department of Economics and Management, University of Ferrara, Via Voltapaletto, 11-44121 Ferrara, Italy.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017 Aug 29;14(9):975. doi: 10.3390/ijerph14090975.
Transnational research networks (TRN) are becoming increasingly complex. Such complexity may have both positive and negative effects on the quality of research. Our work studies the evolution over time of Chinese TRN and the role of complexity on the quality of Chinese research, given the leading role this country has recently acquired in international science. We focus on the fields of geriatrics and gerontology. We build an original dataset of all scientific publications of China in these areas in 2009, 2012 and 2015, starting from the ISI Web of Knowledge (ISI WoK) database. Using Social Network Analysis (SNA), we analyze the change in scientific network structure across time. Second, we design indices to control for the different aspects of networks complexity (number of authors, country heterogeneity and institutional heterogeneity) and we perform negative binomial regressions to identify the main determinants of research quality. Our analysis shows that research networks in the field of geriatrics and gerontology have gradually become wider in terms of countries and have become more balanced. Furthermore, our results identify that different forms of complexity have different impacts on quality, including a reciprocal moderating effect. In particular, according to our analysis, research quality benefits from complex research networks both in terms of countries and of types of institutions involved, but that such networks should be "compact" in terms of number of authors. Eventually, we suggest that complexity should be carefully taken into account when designing policies aimed at enhancing the quality of research.
跨国研究网络(TRN)正变得日益复杂。这种复杂性可能对研究质量产生积极和消极的影响。鉴于中国最近在国际科学领域占据主导地位,我们的研究考察了中国跨国研究网络随时间的演变以及复杂性对中国研究质量的作用。我们聚焦于老年医学和老年学领域。我们从ISI科学网数据库(ISI WoK)入手,构建了一个包含2009年、2012年和2015年中国在这些领域所有科学出版物的原始数据集。利用社会网络分析(SNA),我们分析了科学网络结构随时间的变化。其次,我们设计指标来控制网络复杂性的不同方面(作者数量、国家异质性和机构异质性),并进行负二项回归以确定研究质量的主要决定因素。我们的分析表明,老年医学和老年学领域的研究网络在国家层面上逐渐变得更广泛,且更加平衡。此外,我们的结果表明,不同形式的复杂性对质量有不同影响,包括一种相互调节效应。特别是,根据我们的分析,研究质量在涉及的国家和机构类型方面都受益于复杂的研究网络,但这种网络在作者数量方面应该是“紧凑的”。最后,我们建议在制定旨在提高研究质量的政策时,应仔细考虑复杂性因素。