Kelleher Emily, Harrington Janas M, Shiely Frances, Perry Ivan J, McHugh Sheena M
Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, University College Cork, Cork, Munster, Ireland.
HRB Clinical Research Facility, Mercy University Hospital, Cork, Ireland.
BMJ Open. 2017 Aug 28;7(8):e016459. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-016459.
To explore the barriers and facilitators experienced by those implementing a government-funded, community-based childhood weight management programme.
Qualitative using semistructured interviews.
Two geographical regions in the south and west of Ireland.
29 national-level and local-level stakeholders responsible for implementing the programme, including professionals from dietetics, psychology, public health nursing, physiotherapy, health promotion and administration.
Framework analysis was used to identify barriers and facilitators, which were mapped onto six levels of factors influencing implementation outlined by Grol and Wensing: the innovation, the individual professional, the patient, the social context, the organisational context and the external environment.
Most barriers occurred at the level of the organisational context. For all stakeholders, barriers arose due to the multidisciplinary nature of the programme, including the lack of role clarity and added complexity of working in different locations. Health professionals' low-perceived self-efficacy in approaching the subject of weight with parents and parental resistance to hearing about their child's weight status were barriers to programme implementation at the individual professional and patient levels, respectively. The main facilitators of implementation, occurring at the level of the health professional, included stakeholders' recognition of the need for a weight management programme and personal interest in the area of childhood obesity. Having a local lead and supportive colleagues were further implementation drivers.
This study highlights the complexities associated with implementing a multidisciplinary childhood weight management programme, particularly translating such a programme to a community setting. Our results suggest the assignment of clear roles and responsibilities, the provision of sufficient practical training and resources, and organisational support play pivotal roles in overcoming barriers to change. This evidence can be used to develop an implementation plan to support the translation of interventions into real-world settings.
探讨实施一项政府资助的、基于社区的儿童体重管理项目的人员所经历的障碍和促进因素。
采用半结构化访谈的定性研究。
爱尔兰南部和西部的两个地理区域。
29名负责实施该项目的国家级和地方级利益相关者,包括来自饮食学、心理学、公共卫生护理、物理治疗、健康促进和行政管理等领域的专业人员。
运用框架分析法确定障碍和促进因素,并将其映射到Grol和Wensing概述的影响实施的六个因素层面:创新、个体专业人员、患者、社会背景、组织背景和外部环境。
大多数障碍出现在组织背景层面。对所有利益相关者而言,由于该项目的多学科性质,包括角色不明确以及在不同地点工作增加的复杂性,导致了障碍的出现。在个体专业人员和患者层面,健康专业人员在与家长探讨体重问题时自我效能感较低,以及家长对了解其孩子体重状况存在抵触情绪,分别是项目实施的障碍。实施的主要促进因素出现在健康专业人员层面,包括利益相关者认识到体重管理项目的必要性以及对儿童肥胖领域的个人兴趣。有当地负责人和支持性的同事是进一步推动实施的因素。
本研究突出了实施多学科儿童体重管理项目的复杂性,尤其是将这样一个项目推广到社区环境中。我们的结果表明,明确角色和责任、提供足够的实践培训和资源以及组织支持在克服变革障碍方面发挥着关键作用。这一证据可用于制定实施计划,以支持将干预措施转化为实际应用。