University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev. 2018 Mar;21(1):41-56. doi: 10.1007/s10567-017-0243-4.
The role of parental attributions in parenting interventions has been the subject of intense interest from clinicians and researchers attempting to optimise outcomes in treatments for children with conduct problems. Despite research articulating the many ways parental attributions can influence behavioural parent training (BPT) outcomes, and recognition that addressing parental attributions in treatment is one of the great challenges faced by BPT practitioners, parenting interventions generally do not provide components that explicitly target or focus on changing problematic parental attributions. In this paper, we ask 'Should parental attributions be included into best practice interventions? If so, how can this be done in a way that improves outcomes without cluttering and complicating the parent training model?' We review the theoretical and empirical status of our understanding of the role of parental attributions in BPT with reference to three questions: 'do pre-treatment parental attributions uniquely predict treatment outcomes'; 'do changes in parental attributions uniquely predict treatment outcomes'; and 'does targeting parental attributions in BPT affect treatment outcomes'. Our review indicates that existing research supports the importance of focussing on parental attributions for some families in order to maximise treatment outcomes. However, clinical processes for doing this are yet to be identified and specified in a way that would allow for manualised replication and scrutiny in research designs. We finish with a discussion of how these clinical and research challenges could be approached.
父母归因在养育干预中的作用一直是临床医生和研究人员关注的焦点,他们试图优化针对行为问题儿童的治疗效果。尽管研究阐明了父母归因可以影响行为父母训练(BPT)结果的许多方式,并且认识到在治疗中解决父母归因是 BPT 实践者面临的巨大挑战之一,但养育干预通常没有提供明确针对或专注于改变有问题的父母归因的组成部分。在本文中,我们提出了“父母归因是否应该包含在最佳实践干预中?如果是,如何在不使父母培训模式变得混乱和复杂的情况下做到这一点以提高效果?”我们回顾了我们对父母归因在 BPT 中的作用的理论和经验理解的现状,并参考了三个问题:“治疗前父母归因是否可以独特地预测治疗结果”;“父母归因的变化是否可以独特地预测治疗结果”;以及“BPT 中针对父母归因是否会影响治疗结果”。我们的综述表明,现有研究支持针对某些家庭关注父母归因以最大程度地提高治疗效果的重要性。然而,针对这种情况的临床处理方法尚未确定和具体说明,以便在研究设计中允许进行手动复制和审查。我们最后讨论了如何解决这些临床和研究挑战。