Yao Yi-Sang, Zhu Jia-Shi
Division of Life Sciences and Health, Tsinghua University Graduate School at Shenzhen, Shenzhen 518055, China.
Department of Applied Biology and Chemistry Technology, the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, the Hong Kong, China.
Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi. 2016 Apr;41(7):1361-1366. doi: 10.4268/cjcmm20160733.
Natural Cordyceps sinensis(Dongchongxiacao) is an insect-fungi complex containing multiple Ophiocordyceps sinensis(≡Cordyceps sinensis) fungi and dead body of larva of the family of Hepialidae. But natural C. sinensis and O. sinensis fungi use the same Latin name, resulting in uncertainty of the specific meaning, even disturbing the formulation and implementation of governmental policies and regulations, and influencing consumer psychology onthe market. This paper reviews the history and current status of the indiscriminate use of the Latin name O. sinensis for both the natural insect-fungi complex C. sinensis and O. sinensis fungi and lists the rename suggetions. Some scholars suggested using the term O. sinensis for the fungi and renaming the natural C. sinensis "Chinese cordyceps". Others suggested renaming the natural C. sinensis "Ophiocordyceps & Hepialidae". Both suggestions have not reached general consensus due to various academic concerns. This paper also reviews the exacerbation of the academic uncertainties when forcing implementing the 2011 Amsterdam Declaration "One Fungus=One Name" under the academic debate. Joint efforts of mycological, zoological and botany-TCM taxonomists and properly initiating the dispute systems offered by International Mycology Association may solve the debate on the indiscriminate use of the Latin name O.sinensis for the natural insect-fungi complex,the teleomorph and anamorph(s) of O. sinensis fungi.
天然冬虫夏草是一种虫菌复合体,包含多种中华被毛孢(≡冬虫夏草)真菌以及蝙蝠蛾科幼虫的尸体。但天然冬虫夏草和中华被毛孢真菌使用相同的拉丁名,导致具体含义不明确,甚至干扰政府政策法规的制定与实施,影响市场上消费者的心理。本文回顾了对天然虫菌复合体冬虫夏草和中华被毛孢真菌都不加区分地使用拉丁名中华被毛孢的历史和现状,并列出了重新命名的建议。一些学者建议将中华被毛孢用于指真菌,将天然冬虫夏草重新命名为“中国虫草”。另一些人建议将天然冬虫夏草重新命名为“中华被毛孢与蝙蝠蛾科”。由于各种学术方面的顾虑,这两种建议都尚未达成普遍共识。本文还回顾了在学术争论中强行实施2011年《阿姆斯特丹宣言》“一种真菌=一个名称”时学术不确定性的加剧情况。真菌学、动物学和植物 - 中药分类学家的共同努力以及适当地启动国际真菌协会提供的争议解决机制,可能会解决对天然虫菌复合体、中华被毛孢真菌的有性型和无性型不加区分地使用拉丁名中华被毛孢的争论。