Thomson Rhett S, Auduong Priscilla, Miller Alexander T, Gurgel Richard K
Department of Surgery University of Utah Salt Lake City Utah U.S.A.
Division of Otolaryngology University of Utah Salt Lake City Utah U.S.A.
Laryngoscope Investig Otolaryngol. 2017 Mar 16;2(2):69-79. doi: 10.1002/lio2.65. eCollection 2017 Apr.
To review evidence of hearing loss as a risk factor for dementia. : PubMed : A systematic review was conducted using the PubMed database using the search terms (hearing loss OR presbycusis) AND (dementia OR cognitive decline). Initially, 488 articles were obtained. Only those studies evaluating an association between hearing loss and incident dementia or cognitive decline were included in the analysis. This resulted in 17 articles which were thoroughly evaluated with consideration for study design, method for determining hearing loss and cognitive status, relevant covariates and confounding factors, and key findings.
All of the 17 articles meeting inclusion criteria indicate that hearing loss is associated with dementia or cognitive decline. The methods used among the studies for ascertaining hearing loss and dementia were notably varied. For hearing loss, peripheral auditory function was tested far more than central auditory function. For peripheral audition, pure tone audiometry was the most commonly reported method for defining hearing loss. Only a few studies measured central auditory function by using the Synthetic Sentence Identification with Ipsilateral Competing Message test (SSI-ICM) and the Staggered Spondaic Word Test (SSW). Dementia was most often defined using the Mini Mental State Exam (MMSE). However, many studies used extensive batteries of tests to define cognitive status, often including a neuropsychologist. Confounding variables such as cardiovascular risk factors were measured in 17 studies and family history of dementia was only evaluated in 1 study. Overall, the methods used by studies to ascertain hearing loss, cognitive status and other variables are valid, making their evaluation appear reliable.
While each of the studies included in this study utilized slightly different methods for evaluating participants, each of them demonstrated that hearing loss is associated with higher incidence of dementia in older adults.
Level V, systematic review.
回顾听力损失作为痴呆风险因素的证据。:PubMed:使用PubMed数据库进行系统评价,检索词为(听力损失或老年性聋)和(痴呆或认知衰退)。最初获得488篇文章。分析仅纳入那些评估听力损失与新发痴呆或认知衰退之间关联的研究。这产生了17篇文章,对其进行了全面评估,考虑了研究设计、确定听力损失和认知状态的方法、相关协变量和混杂因素以及主要发现。
符合纳入标准的17篇文章均表明听力损失与痴呆或认知衰退有关。研究中用于确定听力损失和痴呆的方法差异显著。对于听力损失,外周听觉功能的测试远多于中枢听觉功能。对于外周听力,纯音听力测定是最常报告的定义听力损失的方法。只有少数研究通过使用同侧竞争信息合成句识别测试(SSI-ICM)和交错扬扬格词测试(SSW)来测量中枢听觉功能。痴呆最常使用简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)来定义。然而,许多研究使用大量测试组合来定义认知状态,通常包括一名神经心理学家。17项研究测量了心血管危险因素等混杂变量,只有1项研究评估了痴呆家族史。总体而言,研究用于确定听力损失、认知状态和其他变量的方法是有效的,使其评估看起来可靠。
虽然本研究纳入的每项研究评估参与者的方法略有不同,但每项研究都表明听力损失与老年人痴呆发病率较高有关。
V级,系统评价。