Yu Qiuhua, Chan Chetwyn C H, Chau Bolton, Fu Amy S N
Applied Cognitive Neuroscience Laboratory, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong.
Applied Cognitive Neuroscience Laboratory, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2017 Oct;180:88-97. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2017.08.013. Epub 2017 Sep 15.
This study aimed to investigate the effect of types of motor skills, including open and closed skills on enhancing proactive and reactive controls for task switching. Thirty-six athletes in open (n=18) or closed (n=18) sports and a control group (n=18) completed the task-switching paradigm and the simple reaction task. The task-switching paradigm drew on the proactive and reactive control of executive functions, whereas the simple reaction task assessed the processing speed. Significant Validity×Group effect revealed that the participants with open skills had a lower switch cost of response time compared to the other two groups when the task cue was 100% valid; whereas the participants regardless of motor skills had a lower switch cost of response time compared to the control group when the task cue was 50% valid. Hierarchical stepwise regression analysis further confirmed these findings. For the simple reaction task, there were no differences found among the three groups. These findings suggest that experience in open skills has benefits of promoting both proactive and reactive controls for task switching, which corresponds to the activity context exposed by the participants. In contrast, experience in closed skills appears to only benefit development of reactive control for task switching. The neural mechanisms for the proactive and reactive controls of executive functions between experts with open and closed skills call for future study.
本研究旨在探讨运动技能类型(包括开放性技能和封闭性技能)对增强任务转换中的前瞻性和反应性控制的影响。36名从事开放性运动(n = 18)或封闭性运动(n = 18)的运动员以及一个对照组(n = 18)完成了任务转换范式和简单反应任务。任务转换范式利用了执行功能的前瞻性和反应性控制,而简单反应任务评估了处理速度。显著的效度×组别效应表明,当任务线索100%有效时,具有开放性技能的参与者与其他两组相比,反应时间的切换成本更低;而当任务线索50%有效时,无论运动技能如何,参与者与对照组相比,反应时间的切换成本更低。分层逐步回归分析进一步证实了这些发现。对于简单反应任务,三组之间未发现差异。这些发现表明,开放性技能的经验有利于促进任务转换中的前瞻性和反应性控制,这与参与者所接触的活动情境相对应。相比之下,封闭性技能的经验似乎仅有利于任务转换中反应性控制的发展。开放性和封闭性技能专家之间执行功能的前瞻性和反应性控制的神经机制有待未来研究。