University of Oxford, United Kingdom, and IZA, Germany.
Universitat d'Alacant, Spain.
J Health Econ. 2017 Dec;56:47-60. doi: 10.1016/j.jhealeco.2017.08.006. Epub 2017 Sep 4.
We study the effects of in utero exposure to terrorism in Spain on birth outcomes, focusing on terrorism perpetrated by ETA during the period 1980-2003. We find that in utero exposure to terrorism early in pregnancy, as measured by the number of bomb casualties in the mother's province of residence in the first trimester of pregnancy, has detrimental effects on birth outcomes: in terms of average birth weight (lower), prevalence of low birth weight (higher) and fraction of "normal" babies (lower). While our findings are robust to a host of potential threats to validity, they seem to be driven by exposure to a relatively large number of bomb casualties. Focusing on the deadliest ETA terrorist attack, the Hipercor bombing of 1987 in Barcelona, we find substantial effects on birth outcomes. We then attempt to assess the mechanisms at stake by presenting evidence suggesting that exposure to bomb casualties decreases self-reported health and increases smoking among women, but not among men. While exposure to terrorism during conception does not affect total fertility, there seems to be a compositional change: during bombing periods, those women who conceive are more likely to be married, and married women tend to have better birth outcomes, on average. In addition, we find that exposure to bomb casualties increases fetal deaths. Thus, we interpret our estimated negative effects on health at birth as providing lower bounds to the true effects of in utero exposure to terrorism.
我们研究了西班牙子宫内暴露于恐怖主义对生育结果的影响,重点关注 ETA 在 1980-2003 年期间实施的恐怖主义。我们发现,怀孕早期母亲居住地省份的炸弹伤亡人数(以妊娠早期的炸弹伤亡人数来衡量)与生育结果呈负相关:平均出生体重(较低)、低出生体重的比例(较高)和“正常”婴儿的比例(较低)。虽然我们的发现对各种有效性的潜在威胁具有稳健性,但这些发现似乎是由暴露于相对大量的炸弹伤亡人数所驱动的。我们关注 ETA 最致命的恐怖袭击之一,即 1987 年在巴塞罗那发生的 Hipercor 爆炸事件,发现其对生育结果有重大影响。然后,我们通过提供证据表明,接触炸弹伤亡人数会降低女性的自我报告健康状况并增加吸烟,而不会影响男性,从而试图评估所涉及的机制。虽然怀孕期间接触恐怖主义不会影响总生育率,但似乎存在构成性变化:在爆炸期间,怀孕的女性更有可能已婚,而已婚女性的生育结果通常更好。此外,我们发现接触炸弹伤亡人数会增加胎儿死亡。因此,我们将估计的对出生时健康的负面影响解释为对子宫内接触恐怖主义的真实影响的下限。