Marinangeli Christopher P F, House James D
Pulse Canada, Winnipeg, Canada.
Department of Food & Human Nutritional Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada.
Nutr Rev. 2017 Aug 1;75(8):658-667. doi: 10.1093/nutrit/nux025.
Regulatory frameworks for protein content claims in Canada and the United States are underpinned by the protein efficiency ratio and protein digestibility-corrected amino acid score (PDCAAS), respectively, which are used to assess the protein quality of a given food. The digestible indispensable amino acid score (DIAAS) is a novel approach to measuring the protein quality of foods and is supported by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Methodological concerns about the PDCAAS are addressed by the DIAAS through introduction of the use of ileal amino acid digestibility coefficients and untruncated protein scores. However, before the DIAAS is widely adopted within regulatory frameworks, a comprehensive assessment is required. Accordingly, this review addresses the potential impact of the DIAAS on regulation, communication, and public health, as well as knowledge gaps, analytical challenges, and cost of implementation. A pragmatic approach to addressing protein quality is advocated by suggesting the use of conservative coefficients of digestibility that are derived from in vitro methods. Before adopting the DIAAS as a framework for supporting protein content claims, updated food-related regulations and policies should also be evaluated through a lens that anticipates the impact on consumer-facing nutrition communication, the adoption of dietary patterns that are nutritionally adequate, and a food value chain that fosters a spirit of food and nutritional innovation.
加拿大和美国关于蛋白质含量声明的监管框架分别以蛋白质效率比和蛋白质消化率校正氨基酸评分(PDCAAS)为基础,这两个指标用于评估特定食物的蛋白质质量。可消化必需氨基酸评分(DIAAS)是一种衡量食物蛋白质质量的新方法,得到了联合国粮食及农业组织的支持。DIAAS通过引入回肠氨基酸消化率系数和未截断的蛋白质评分,解决了对PDCAAS的方法学问题。然而,在监管框架中广泛采用DIAAS之前,需要进行全面评估。因此,本综述探讨了DIAAS对监管、沟通和公共卫生的潜在影响,以及知识差距、分析挑战和实施成本。通过建议使用源自体外方法的保守消化率系数,倡导一种务实的解决蛋白质质量问题的方法。在采用DIAAS作为支持蛋白质含量声明的框架之前,还应通过一个视角来评估更新后的食品相关法规和政策,该视角应预见到对面向消费者的营养沟通、采用营养充足的饮食模式以及促进食品和营养创新精神的食品价值链的影响。