Kim Hyerim, Chang Jee-Eun, Han Sung-Hee, Lee Jung-Man, Yoon Soohyuk, Hwang Jin-Young
Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, SMG-SNU Boramae Medical Center, Republic of Korea.
Department of Anesthesiology & Pain Medicine, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Republic of Korea.
Am J Emerg Med. 2018 Jan;36(1):120-123. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2017.09.050. Epub 2017 Sep 28.
In the present study, we compared the laryngoscopic view depending on the size of the Macintosh curved blade in edentulous patients.
Thirty-five edentulous adult patients scheduled for elective surgery were included in the study. After induction of anesthesia, two direct laryngoscopies were performed alternately using a standard-sized Macintosh curved blade (No. 4 for men and No. 3 for women) and smaller-sized Macintosh curved blade (No. 3 for men and No. 2 for women). During direct laryngoscopy with each blade, two digital photographs of the lateral view were taken when the blade tip was placed in the valleculae; the laryngoscope was lifted to achieve the best laryngeal view. Then, the best laryngeal views were assessed using the percentage of glottic opening (POGO) score. On the photographs of the lateral view of direct laryngoscopy, the angles between the line extending along the laryngoscopic handle and the horizontal line were measured.
The POGO score was improved with the smaller-sized blade compared with the standard-sized blade (87.3% [11.8%] vs. 71.3% [20.0%], P<0.001, respectively). The angles between the laryngoscopic handle and the horizontal line were greater with the smaller-sized blade compared to the standard-sized blade when the blade tip was placed on the valleculae and when the laryngoscope was lifted to achieve the best laryngeal view (both P<0.001).
Compared to a standard-sized Macintosh blade, a smaller-sized Macintosh curved blade improved the laryngeal exposure in edentulous patients.
在本研究中,我们比较了无牙患者使用不同尺寸麦金托什弯喉镜片时的喉镜视野。
35例计划接受择期手术的无牙成年患者纳入本研究。麻醉诱导后,交替使用标准尺寸的麦金托什弯喉镜片(男性用4号,女性用3号)和较小尺寸的麦金托什弯喉镜片(男性用3号,女性用2号)进行两次直接喉镜检查。在每次使用镜片进行直接喉镜检查时,当镜片尖端置于会厌谷时,拍摄两张侧视图数码照片;提起喉镜以获得最佳的喉部视野。然后,使用声门开口百分比(POGO)评分评估最佳喉部视野。在直接喉镜检查侧视图照片上,测量沿喉镜手柄延伸的线与水平线之间的角度。
与标准尺寸镜片相比,较小尺寸镜片的POGO评分有所提高(分别为87.3%[11.8%]和71.3%[20.0%],P<0.001)。当镜片尖端置于会厌谷且提起喉镜以获得最佳喉部视野时,较小尺寸镜片的喉镜手柄与水平线之间的角度大于标准尺寸镜片(均P<0.001)。
与标准尺寸的麦金托什镜片相比,较小尺寸的麦金托什弯喉镜片可改善无牙患者的喉部暴露。