Birn Anne-Emanuelle, Muntaner Carles, Afzal Zabia
Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Bloomberg Faculty of Nursing, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Cad Saude Publica. 2017 Oct 2;33Suppl 2(Suppl 2):e00194616. doi: 10.1590/0102-311X00194616.
Since the mid-2000s, the practice of South-South cooperation in health (SSC) has attracted growing attention among policymakers, health and foreign affairs ministries, global health agencies, and scholars from a range of fields. But the South-South label elucidates little about the actual content of the cooperation and conflates the "where" with the "who, what, how, and why". While there have been some attempts to theorize global health diplomacy and South-South cooperation generally, these efforts do not sufficiently distinguish among the different kinds of practices and political values that fall under the South-South rubric, ranging from economic and geopolitical interests to social justice forms of solidarity. In the spirit of deepening theoretical, historical, and social justice analyses of SSC, this article: (1) critically revisits international relations theories that seek to explain SSC, exploring Marxian and other heterodox theories ignored in the mainstream literature; (2) traces the historical provenance of a variety of forms of SSC; and (3) introduces the concept of social justice-oriented South-South.
自21世纪中叶以来,卫生领域的南南合作实践已引起政策制定者、卫生和外交部、全球卫生机构以及众多领域学者越来越多的关注。但“南南”这一标签几乎没有阐明合作的实际内容,并且将“地点”与“主体、内容、方式及原因”混为一谈。尽管已有一些尝试对全球卫生外交及南南合作进行总体理论化,但这些努力并未充分区分南南框架下不同类型的实践和政治价值观,这些价值观涵盖从经济和地缘政治利益到社会正义团结形式等各个方面。本着深化对南南合作进行理论、历史及社会正义分析的精神,本文:(1)批判性地回顾试图解释南南合作的国际关系理论,探讨主流文献中被忽视的马克思主义及其他非正统理论;(2)追溯各种南南合作形式的历史渊源;(3)引入以社会正义为导向的南南合作概念。