Department of Family Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
Centre for Outcomes Research & Evaluation, Research Institute of the McGill University Health Centre, 5252 Boul de Maisonneuve, 3C.35, Montreal, QC, H4A 3S5, Canada.
Qual Life Res. 2018 Feb;27(2):379-388. doi: 10.1007/s11136-017-1711-5. Epub 2017 Oct 13.
To identify HIV clinicians' needs for the clinical use of a new patient-reported outcome measure (PRO) on barriers to antiretroviral therapy (ART) adherence.
In 2015, five focus groups with 31 clinicians from France were transcribed, coded with Atlas.ti, and submitted to a typological analysis.
The analysis identified seven patient profiles, each tied to distinct barriers to adherence and to specific needs for the PRO's content, data collection and transmission. Clinicians preferred, for the patient who is: (1) 'passive,' that the PRO collect information on ART knowledge, to ensure that the prescription's instructions are being respected; (2) 'misleading,' that it be able to detect adherence to ART and socially desirable responses; (3) 'stoic,' that questions challenge the patient to recognize treatment-specific side effects; (4) 'hedonistic,' that the PRO contains content on lifestyle and risk-taking; (5) 'obsessive,' that the PRO captures quality of life and stressful life events; (6) 'overburdened,' that the PRO provides information on the person's home environment, socioeconomic status and cultural constraints. For all or most patient profiles, the clinicians wished that the PRO be completed, minimally, prior to the medical consultation and to receive alerts, under varying conditions, when problematic scores were detected. Depending on the profile, there was preference for the inclusion of open-ended questions and transmission of cross-sectional, periodic or longitudinal PRO data.
Overall, this study's findings suggest that to support the clinical management of ART adherence, our PRO must meet the needs of a wide variety of patients and must perform multiple functions.
确定 HIV 临床医生在抗逆转录病毒治疗 (ART) 依从性障碍的临床应用中对新的患者报告结局测量 (PRO) 的需求。
2015 年,对来自法国的 31 名临床医生进行了 5 次焦点小组讨论,使用 Atlas.ti 进行转录、编码,并提交进行类型分析。
分析确定了 7 种患者特征,每种特征都与特定的依从性障碍以及对 PRO 的内容、数据收集和传输的特定需求相关。临床医生更希望 PRO 收集有关 ART 知识的信息,以确保处方说明得到遵守:(1) “被动”患者;(2) “误导”患者,以便能够检测对 ART 的依从性和社会期望反应;(3) “坚韧不拔”患者,提出挑战以让患者认识到与治疗相关的副作用;(4) “享乐主义”患者,PRO 包含有关生活方式和冒险行为的内容;(5) “强迫性”患者,PRO 捕捉生活质量和压力生活事件;(6) “负担过重”患者,PRO 提供有关患者家庭环境、社会经济地位和文化限制的信息。对于所有或大多数患者特征,临床医生希望 PRO 在医疗咨询之前最少完成一次,并在检测到有问题的分数时,在不同条件下接收警报。根据患者特征,存在对开放式问题的偏好,以及对横断面、定期或纵向 PRO 数据的传输偏好。
总体而言,本研究的结果表明,为了支持 ART 依从性的临床管理,我们的 PRO 必须满足各种患者的需求,并执行多种功能。