Li Kai, Lindauer Charlotte, Haase Rocco, Rüdiger Heinz, Reichmann Heinz, Reuner Ulrike, Ziemssen Tjalf
Department of Neurology, Center of Clinical Neuroscience, University Hospital Carl Gustav Carus, Dresden University of Technology, Dresden, Germany.
Department of Neurology, Beijing Hospital, National Center of Gerontology, Beijing, China.
Front Physiol. 2017 Oct 10;8:778. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2017.00778. eCollection 2017.
Wilson's disease is reported to have autonomic dysfunction, but comprehensive evaluation of autonomic function is lacking. Additionally, little is known about the change of autonomic function of Wilson's disease during continuous therapy. We assumed that patients with Wilson's disease had both sympathetic and parasympathetic autonomic impairments, and the autonomic dysfunction might be stable across a 3-year follow-up after years of optimal treatment. Twenty-six patients with Wilson's disease and twenty-six healthy controls were recruited. Twenty patients in the Wilson's disease group were examined again after a 3-year follow-up. All the participants were evaluated by a questionnaire on dysautonomia symptoms, 24-h blood pressure and heart rate monitoring, and cardiovascular autonomic function examination in various conditions including at rest, deep breathing, Valsalva maneuver, isometric handgrip test and passive tilting. Baroreflex sensitivity and spectral analyses were performed via trigonometric regressive spectral analysis. Patients with Wilson's disease showed autonomic dysfunction mainly in the following aspects: (1) the heart rate was higher than the controls. (2) Valsalva ratio was lower in patients with Wilson's disease compared with the controls. (3) Heart rate increase during isometric hand gripping was smaller in the Wilson's disease patients than the controls. (4) Baroreflex sensitivity was lower during nearly all the cardiovascular autonomic function examinations compared with healthy controls. When tested 3 years later, baroreflex sensitivity at rest decreased compared with baseline. (5) There were mild declines of resting DBP and low frequency component of heart rate variability during the follow-up examination compared with baseline. (6) Subgroup analysis showed that patients initially presenting with neurological symptoms had a higher night-time heart rate, lower expiration: inspiration RR interval ratio (E/I ratio), lower expiration: inspiration RR interval difference (E-I difference), less increase of heart rate and diastolic blood pressure during the handgrip test, and lower baroreflex sensitivity during deep breathing than the control group. (7) Correlation analysis showed that the severity of neurological symptoms was associated with E/I ratio, E-I difference, Valsalva ratio, heart rate change during the handgrip test, and baroreflex sensitivity during deep breathing. The present study reveals cardiovascular autonomic dysfunction involving both sympathetic and parasympathetic branches in Wilson's disease patients, which is especially significant in the patients with neurological onset. Autonomic function is generally stable undergoing optimal maintenance treatment in patients with Wilson's disease. Though there might be mild changes of specific parameters.
据报道,威尔逊氏病存在自主神经功能障碍,但缺乏对自主神经功能的全面评估。此外,对于威尔逊氏病患者在持续治疗期间自主神经功能的变化了解甚少。我们假设威尔逊氏病患者同时存在交感神经和副交感神经自主神经损伤,并且在经过数年的最佳治疗后,自主神经功能障碍在3年的随访期内可能保持稳定。招募了26例威尔逊氏病患者和26名健康对照者。威尔逊氏病组中的20例患者在3年随访后再次接受检查。所有参与者均通过自主神经功能障碍症状问卷、24小时血压和心率监测以及在静息、深呼吸、瓦尔萨尔瓦动作、等长握力试验和被动倾斜等各种情况下的心血管自主神经功能检查进行评估。通过三角回归频谱分析进行压力反射敏感性和频谱分析。威尔逊氏病患者的自主神经功能障碍主要表现在以下几个方面:(1)心率高于对照组。(2)威尔逊氏病患者的瓦尔萨尔瓦比值低于对照组。(3)威尔逊氏病患者在等长握力试验期间心率增加幅度小于对照组。(4)与健康对照相比,在几乎所有心血管自主神经功能检查期间压力反射敏感性均较低。在3年后进行测试时,静息时的压力反射敏感性与基线相比有所下降。(5)与基线相比,随访检查期间静息舒张压和心率变异性的低频成分有轻度下降。(6)亚组分析表明,最初表现为神经症状的患者夜间心率较高,呼气:吸气RR间期比值(E/I比值)较低,呼气:吸气RR间期差值(E-I差值)较低,握力试验期间心率和舒张压增加较少,深呼吸时压力反射敏感性低于对照组。(7)相关性分析表明,神经症状的严重程度与E/I比值、E-I差值、瓦尔萨尔瓦比值、握力试验期间的心率变化以及深呼吸时的压力反射敏感性相关。本研究揭示了威尔逊氏病患者存在涉及交感神经和副交感神经分支的心血管自主神经功能障碍,这在以神经症状起病的患者中尤为明显。威尔逊氏病患者在接受最佳维持治疗时自主神经功能一般稳定。尽管特定参数可能会有轻微变化。