Leow Li-Ann, Waclawik Kristina, Grahn Jessica A
Centre for Sensorimotor Performance, School of Human Movement and Nutrition Sciences, Building 26B, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD, 4072, Australia.
Department of Psychology, University of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada.
Exp Brain Res. 2018 Jan;236(1):99-115. doi: 10.1007/s00221-017-5110-5. Epub 2017 Oct 26.
Anecdotal accounts suggest that individuals spontaneously synchronize their movements to the 'beat' of background music, often without intending to, and perhaps even without attending to the music at all. However, the question of whether intention and attention are necessary to synchronize to the beat remains unclear. Here, we compared whether footsteps during overground walking were synchronized to the beat when young healthy adults were explicitly instructed to synchronize (intention to synchronize), and were not instructed to synchronize (no intention) (Experiment 1: intention). We also examined whether reducing participants' attention to the music affected synchronization, again when participants were explicitly instructed to synchronize, and when they were not (Experiment 2: attention/intention). Synchronization was much less frequent when no instructions to synchronize were given. Without explicit instructions to synchronize, there was no evidence of synchronization in 60% of the trials in Experiment 1, and 43% of the trials in Experiment 2. When instructed to synchronize, only 26% of trials in Experiment 1, and 14% of trials in Experiment 2 showed no evidence of synchronization. Because walking to music alters gait, we also examined how gait kinematics changed with or without instructions to synchronize, and attention to the music was required for synchronization to occur. Instructions to synchronize elicited slower, shorter, and more variable strides than walking in silence. Reducing attention to the music did not significantly affect synchronization of footsteps to the beat, but did elicit slower gait. Thus, during walking, intention, but not attention, appears to be necessary to synchronize footsteps to the beat, and synchronization elicits slower, shorter, and more variable strides, at least in young healthy adults.
轶事记录表明,人们常常会不由自主地将自己的动作与背景音乐的“节奏”同步,而且往往是无意为之,甚至可能根本没有留意音乐。然而,与节奏同步是否需要意图和注意力,这个问题仍不明确。在此,我们比较了在两种情况下,年轻健康成年人在地面行走时脚步是否会与节奏同步:一种是明确指示他们同步(有同步意图),另一种是没有指示他们同步(无同步意图)(实验1:意图)。我们还研究了在参与者被明确指示同步以及未被指示同步的情况下,减少他们对音乐的注意力是否会影响同步(实验2:注意力/意图)。当没有给出同步指示时,同步的情况要少得多。在没有明确同步指示的情况下,实验1中60%的试验和实验2中43%的试验没有同步的迹象。当被指示同步时,实验1中只有26%的试验和实验2中14%的试验没有同步的迹象。因为随着音乐行走会改变步态,所以我们还研究了在有无同步指示的情况下步态运动学是如何变化的,以及同步发生是否需要对音乐的关注。与安静行走相比,同步指示会导致步幅更慢、更短且更不稳定。减少对音乐的注意力并没有显著影响脚步与节奏的同步,但确实导致了步态变慢。因此,在行走过程中,与节奏同步脚步似乎需要意图,而不是注意力,并且同步会导致步幅更慢、更短且更不稳定,至少在年轻健康成年人中是这样。