Bruyneel Luk, Tambuyzer Else, Coeckelberghs Ellen, De Wachter Dirk, Sermeus Walter, De Ridder Dirk, Ramaekers Dirk, Weeghmans Ilse, Vanhaecht Kris
KU Leuven Institute for Healthcare Policy, University of Leuven, Kapucijnenvoer 35, 3000 Leuven, Belgium.
Flemish Patient Platform, Groenveldstraat 15, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017 Oct 30;14(11):1319. doi: 10.3390/ijerph14111319.
Implementing a standardized patient experience survey may initiate a process to apply pressure on hospitals to attend to improving patient experiences. In Flanders, Belgium, the Flemish Patient Survey was developed between 2011 and 2015. A preliminary version was developed from a scoping review and patient and expert focus groups, and included 27 items for eight hypothesized dimensions: 'preparing for hospital stay', 'information and communication', 'coordination', 'respect', 'privacy', 'safe care', pain management', and 'participation'. Exploratory factor analysis for 1076 patients in 17 hospitals found that the data did not fit the dimensions. Adaptations in item wording and response categories were based on the US Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems. The revised version showed excellent model fit in 22,143 patients in 37 hospitals. Multiple group analysis pointed to evidence of measurement invariance over time across mode of administration, type of nursing unit, and various patient characteristics. Fostering a collaborative approach thus proved successful in implementing a standardized patient experience survey. The most recent findings (2016) illustrate substandard performance and a need for patient-mix adjustment. The Flemish government developed a dedicated website to make findings publicly available and the federal government currently considers patient experiences in devising a pay-for-quality scheme.
实施标准化的患者体验调查可能会启动一个向医院施压以改善患者体验的过程。在比利时的弗拉芒地区,2011年至2015年间开展了弗拉芒患者调查。其初稿基于范围综述以及患者和专家焦点小组制定,包含针对八个假设维度的27个项目:“住院准备”“信息与沟通”“协调”“尊重”“隐私”“安全护理”“疼痛管理”和“参与”。对17家医院的1076名患者进行的探索性因素分析发现,数据并不符合这些维度。项目措辞和回答类别根据美国医疗服务提供者与系统消费者评估进行了调整。修订版在37家医院的22143名患者中显示出极佳的模型拟合度。多组分析表明,在管理模式、护理单元类型和各种患者特征方面,随时间推移存在测量不变性的证据。因此,事实证明采用协作方法成功实施了标准化的患者体验调查。最新研究结果(2016年)表明存在表现不佳的情况,且需要对患者组合进行调整。弗拉芒政府设立了一个专门网站来公开研究结果,联邦政府目前在设计质量付费计划时会考虑患者体验。