Carballeira Rafael, Vieira Duarte N, Febrero-Bande Manuel, Muñoz Barús José I
Institute of Forensic Sciences, University of Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela, Spain.
Department of Botany, Faculty of Biology, University of Santiago de Compostela, Santiago de Compostela, Spain.
Int J Legal Med. 2018 Mar;132(2):487-497. doi: 10.1007/s00414-017-1708-1. Epub 2017 Nov 8.
The diatom test is considered a useful aid in determining the site of death from drowning. Nevertheless, there is disagreement within the scientific community concerning its reliability, and its findings have been challenged and sometimes overturned in courts of law. Using a model based on animal experimentation, we have developed a diatom test to discriminate between the locations of drowning sites from different aquatic systems. We carried out a complementary combination of quantitative and qualitative analyses together with a statistical analysis based on the Kullback-Leibler distance of the samples. A restrictive selection of exclusive diatom species from each reservoir was also made. This approach allowed us to validate the usefulness of the diatom test in determining the location of the site of drowning.
硅藻检验被认为是确定溺水死亡地点的一项有用辅助手段。然而,科学界对于其可靠性存在分歧,其检验结果在法庭上也受到质疑,有时甚至被推翻。我们基于动物实验建立了一个模型,开发了一种硅藻检验方法,以区分不同水生系统中溺水地点。我们将定量分析与定性分析相结合,并基于样本的库尔贝克-莱布勒距离进行统计分析。我们还从每个水库中严格挑选了独特的硅藻物种。这种方法使我们能够验证硅藻检验在确定溺水地点方面的有效性。