Greenwald A G, Klinger M R, Liu T J
Mem Cognit. 1989 Jan;17(1):35-47. doi: 10.3758/bf03199555.
In three experiments, the subjects' task was to decide whether each of a series of words connoted something good (e.g., fame, comedy, rescue) or bad (stress, detest, malaria). One-half second before the presentation of each such target word, an evaluatively polarized priming word was presented briefly to the nondominant eye and was masked dichoptically by either the rapidly following (Experiment 1) or simultaneous (Experiments 2 and 3) presentation of a random letter-fragment pattern to the dominant eye. (The effectiveness of the masking procedure was demonstrated by the subjects' inability to discriminate the left vs. right position of a test series of words.) In all experiments, significant masked priming effects were obtained; evaluative decisions to congruent masked prime-target combinations (such as a positive masked prime followed by a positive target) were significantly faster than those to incongruent (e.g., negative prime/positive target) or noncongruent (e.g., neutral prime/positive target) combinations. Also, in two of the three experiments, when subjects were at chance accuracy in discriminating word position, their position judgments were nevertheless significantly influenced by the irrelevant semantic content (LEFT vs. RIGHT) of the masked position-varying words. The series of experiments demonstrated that two very different tasks--speeded judgment of evaluative meaning and nonspeeded judgment of word position--yielded statistically significant and replicable influences of the semantic content of apparently undetectable words. Coupled with previous research by others using the lexical decision task, these findings converge in establishing the reliability of the empirical phenomenon of semantic processing of words that are rendered undetectable by dichoptic pattern masking.
在三项实验中,受试者的任务是判断一系列单词中的每一个所隐含的是好的事物(如名声、喜剧、救援)还是坏的事物(压力、厌恶、疟疾)。在每个这样的目标单词呈现前半秒,一个具有评价性两极分化的启动词会短暂呈现给非优势眼,并通过随后快速呈现(实验1)或同时呈现(实验2和3)给优势眼的随机字母片段图案进行双眼分视掩蔽。(受试者无法区分测试单词系列的左右位置,这证明了掩蔽程序的有效性。)在所有实验中,都获得了显著的掩蔽启动效应;对一致的掩蔽启动-目标组合(如正性掩蔽启动后跟正性目标)的评价性决策显著快于对不一致组合(如负性启动/正性目标)或非一致组合(如中性启动/正性目标)的决策。此外,在三项实验中的两项里,当受试者在区分单词位置上处于随机准确率时,他们的位置判断仍然受到掩蔽的位置变化单词的无关语义内容(左与右)的显著影响。这一系列实验表明,两项非常不同的任务——对评价意义的快速判断和对单词位置的非快速判断——产生了由明显不可察觉的单词的语义内容所带来的具有统计学显著性且可重复的影响。与其他人之前使用词汇判断任务的研究相结合,这些发现共同确立了通过双眼分视图案掩蔽使其不可察觉的单词的语义加工这一实证现象的可靠性。