Lanska Douglas J
VA Medical Center, Great Lakes VA Healthcare System, Tomah, WI, USA.
Front Neurol Neurosci. 2018;42:122-131. doi: 10.1159/000475700. Epub 2017 Nov 17.
In the late 19th century, jumping (French Canadians in Maine, USA), miryachit (Siberia), and latah (Southeast Asia) were among a group of similar disorders described around the world, each of which manifests as an exaggerated startle response with additional late-response features that were felt by some to overlap with hysteria or tics. The later features following the exaggerated startle reaction variably include mimesis (e.g., echopraxia, echolalia) and automatic obedience. These reaction patterns tended to persist indefinitely in affected individuals. Because of their dramatic stimulus-driven behaviors, affected individuals were prone to be teased and tormented by being repeatedly and intentionally startled. Despite clinical overlap between jumping and Tourette syndrome, these entities are now recognized as distinct: in jumping, the key feature is an abnormal startle response, the abnormal reaction is always provoked, and tics are absent, whereas in Tourette syndrome, the key feature is spontaneous motor and vocal tics, although patients with Tourette syndrome may occasionally also have an exaggerated startle response. These disorders have been conceptualized from anthropological, psychodynamic, and neurobiologic perspectives, with no complete resolution to date. Attempts at treatment have been generally unsuccessful, including attempts with bromization and hypnosis, although anecdotal reports of successful deconditioning have been published. In population groups affected, these disorders are usually considered as behavioral peculiarities and not as diseases per se, and there is no apparent tendency to develop disabling mental illness or neurodegenerative disorders. The genesis of these disorders, their cultural and social components, and their interactions with the presumed underlying physiological substrate need further study. Careful descriptive and analytic epidemiological studies are also lacking for all of these disorders.
19世纪后期,跳跃症(美国缅因州的法裔加拿大人中出现)、米里亚基特症(西伯利亚地区)和 latah 症(东南亚地区)是世界各地描述的一组类似疾病,每一种都表现为夸张的惊吓反应,并伴有一些后期反应特征,有些人认为这些特征与癔症或抽动症有重叠。夸张的惊吓反应之后的后期特征各不相同,包括模仿行为(如模仿动作、模仿言语)和自动服从。这些反应模式在受影响个体中往往会无限期持续。由于其受刺激驱动的戏剧性行为,受影响个体容易因被反复故意惊吓而遭到取笑和折磨。尽管跳跃症和图雷特综合征在临床上有重叠,但现在人们认识到它们是不同的:在跳跃症中,关键特征是异常的惊吓反应,异常反应总是由刺激引发,且没有抽动症状,而在图雷特综合征中,关键特征是自发的运动和发声抽动,尽管图雷特综合征患者偶尔也可能有夸张的惊吓反应。这些疾病已从人类学、心理动力学和神经生物学角度进行了概念化,但至今仍未完全解决。治疗尝试总体上都没有成功,包括使用溴化法和催眠的尝试,不过也有成功消除条件反射的轶事报道发表。在受影响的人群中,这些疾病通常被视为行为特点,而非疾病本身,并且没有明显的发展为致残性精神疾病或神经退行性疾病的倾向。这些疾病的成因、其文化和社会成分以及它们与假定的潜在生理基质的相互作用需要进一步研究。对于所有这些疾病,也缺乏细致的描述性和分析性流行病学研究。