Shaw Jonathan, Saunders John Michael, Hughes Gwenda
1 The Centre: Incorporating Contraception, GUM and HIV Services, Exeter, UK.
2 HIV & STI Department, 371011 Public Health England , London, UK.
Int J STD AIDS. 2018 May;29(6):547-551. doi: 10.1177/0956462417742318. Epub 2017 Nov 20.
Chlamydia trachomatis and Neisseria gonorrhoeae testing guidance recommends extragenital screening with locally validated nucleic acid amplification tests, with anatomical sites tested separately. Evidence supports multi-patient combined aliquot pooled sampling (PS) for population screening; evidence for within-patient PS is sparse. Within-patient PS could be more cost-effective for triple-site testing, but requires distinct clinical pathways and consideration over loss of information to guide risk assessments and treatment. We explored PS attitudes and practices amongst clinicians in England. A cross-sectional web-based survey was distributed to clinical leads of sexual health services throughout England in February 2016. Fifty-two (52/216, 23%) services responded. One service reported current within-patient PS and two were awaiting implementation. Of the 49 services not pooling, five were considering implementation. Concerns raised included the inability to distinguish infection site(s) (36/52, 69%), absence of national guidance (34/52, 65%) and reduced assay performance (18/52, 34%). Only 8/52 (15%) considered the current level of evidence sufficient to support PS, with 40/52 (77%) requesting further validation studies and 39/52 (77%) national guidance. PS was rarely used by respondents to this survey, although the response rate was low. The clinical challenges presented by PS need to be addressed through further development of the evidence base.
沙眼衣原体和淋病奈瑟菌检测指南建议使用经过本地验证的核酸扩增试验进行生殖器外筛查,对不同解剖部位分别进行检测。有证据支持在人群筛查中采用多位患者合并样本混合采样(PS);而关于患者内PS的证据较少。患者内PS对于三位点检测可能更具成本效益,但需要不同的临床路径,并考虑信息损失对风险评估和治疗指导的影响。我们探讨了英格兰临床医生对PS的态度和做法。2016年2月,我们向英格兰各地性健康服务的临床负责人开展了一项基于网络的横断面调查。52家(52/216,23%)服务机构做出了回应。一家服务机构报告了当前的患者内PS情况,两家正在等待实施。在49家未进行混合采样的服务机构中,有五家正在考虑实施。提出的担忧包括无法区分感染部位(36/52,69%)、缺乏国家指南(34/52,65%)以及检测性能下降(18/52,34%)。只有8/52(15%)认为当前的证据水平足以支持PS,40/52(77%)要求进行进一步的验证研究,39/52(77%)要求出台国家指南。尽管本调查的回复率较低,但受访者很少使用PS。PS带来的临床挑战需要通过进一步发展证据基础来解决。