Dowling Alison, Enticott Joanne, Russell Grant
School of Primary Health Care, Monash University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
Department of Psychiatry, Southern Synergy, Monash University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017 Dec 8;17(1):817. doi: 10.1186/s12913-017-2771-5.
The health status of refugees is a significant factor in determining their success in resettlement and relies heavily on self-rated measures of refugee health. The selection of robust and appropriate self-rated health measurement tools is challenging due to the number and methodological variation in the use of assessment tools across refugee health studies. This study describes the existing self-report health measures which have been used in studies of adult refugees living in the community to allow us to address the challenges of selecting appropriate assessments to measure health within refugee groups.
Electronic databases of Ovid Medline, CINAHL, SCOPUS, Embase and Scopus.
This review identified 45 different self-rated health measurements in 183 studies. Most of the studies were cross sectional explorations of the mental health status of refugees living in community settings within Western nations. A third of the tools were designed specifically for use within refugee populations. More than half of the identified measurement tools have been evaluated for reliability and/or validity within refugee populations. Much variation was found in the selection, development and testing of measurement tools across the reviewed studies.
This review shows that there are currently a number of reliable and valid tools available for use in refugee health research; however, further work is required to achieve consistency in the quality and in the use of these tools. Methodological guidelines are required to assist researchers and clinicians in the development and testing of self-rated health measurement tools for use in refugee research.
难民的健康状况是决定其重新安置成功与否的重要因素,并且在很大程度上依赖于难民对自身健康的自评指标。由于难民健康研究中评估工具使用的数量和方法存在差异,选择强大且合适的自评健康测量工具具有挑战性。本研究描述了在社区居住的成年难民研究中使用的现有自我报告健康测量方法,以便我们应对在难民群体中选择合适评估方法来测量健康的挑战。
检索Ovid Medline、CINAHL、SCOPUS、Embase和Scopus电子数据库。
本综述在183项研究中确定了45种不同的自评健康测量方法。大多数研究是对西方国家社区环境中难民心理健康状况的横断面探索。三分之一的工具是专门为在难民群体中使用而设计的。超过一半的已识别测量工具在难民群体中进行了可靠性和/或有效性评估。在所审查的研究中,测量工具的选择、开发和测试存在很大差异。
本综述表明,目前有许多可靠且有效的工具可用于难民健康研究;然而,需要进一步开展工作以实现这些工具在质量和使用方面的一致性。需要方法学指南来协助研究人员和临床医生开发和测试用于难民研究的自评健康测量工具。