World Health Organization, Expanded Programme on Immunization, 20 Avenue Appia, 1211 Geneva, Switzerland.
MMGH Consulting, Kürbergstrasse 1, 8049 Zürich, Switzerland.
Vaccine. 2018 Jan 25;36(4):498-506. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.12.010. Epub 2017 Dec 15.
Over the past decade, several countries across all regions, income groups and procurement methods have been unable to secure sufficient BCG vaccine supply. While the frequency of stock-outs has remained rather stable, duration increased in 2014-2015 due to manufacturing issues and attracted the attention of national, regional and global immunization stakeholders. This prompted an in-depth analysis of supply and demand dynamics aiming to characterize supply risks. This analysis is unique as it provides a global picture, where previous analyses have focused on a portion of the market procuring through UN entities. Through literature review, supplier interviews, appraisal of shortages, stock-outs and historical procurement data, and through demand forecasting, this analysis shows an important increase in global capacity in 2017: supply is sufficient to meet forecasted BCG vaccine demand and possibly buffer market shocks. Nevertheless, risks remain mainly due to supply concentration and limited investment in production process improvements, as well as inflexibility in demand. Identification of these market risks will allow implementation of risk-mitigating interventions in three areas: (1) enhancing information sharing between major global health actors, countries and suppliers, (2) identifying interests and incentives to expand product registration and investment in the BCG manufacturing process, and (3) working with countries for tighter vaccine management.
在过去十年中,许多来自不同地区、收入群体和采购方法的国家都无法确保有足够的卡介苗供应。虽然缺货的频率相对稳定,但由于生产问题,2014-2015 年的缺货持续时间增加,引起了国家、地区和全球免疫利益相关者的关注。这促使人们对供需动态进行深入分析,以确定供应风险的特征。这种分析是独特的,因为它提供了一个全球图景,而以前的分析只关注通过联合国实体采购的市场的一部分。通过文献回顾、供应商访谈、短缺评估、缺货和历史采购数据,并通过需求预测,这项分析表明,全球产能在 2017 年有了重要的增长:供应足以满足预测的卡介苗疫苗需求,并可能缓冲市场冲击。然而,风险仍然主要是由于供应集中和对生产工艺改进的投资有限,以及需求缺乏灵活性。确定这些市场风险将允许在三个领域实施风险缓解干预措施:(1)加强主要全球卫生行为者、国家和供应商之间的信息共享,(2)确定扩大产品注册和投资卡介苗生产过程的利益和动机,以及 (3)与各国合作加强疫苗管理。