Smeijers Danique, Bulten Erik, Buitelaar Jan, Verkes Robbert-Jan
1 Department of Psychiatry, Radboud University Medical Centre Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
2 Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud University, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2018 Sep;62(12):3853-3872. doi: 10.1177/0306624X17750340. Epub 2018 Jan 1.
Aggression Replacement Training (ART) is widely used to reduce aggression and is considered to be effective although there are also inconsistent results. Studies investigating the effectiveness of ART do not focus on neurocognitive characteristics. Focusing on these aspects would result in enhanced understanding of underlying mechanisms of ART. The current open uncontrolled treatment study assessed whether neurocognitive characteristics were associated with change in aggression during the social skills and anger control modules of ART among forensic psychiatric outpatients. Furthermore, differences between treatment dropouts and completers and change in these characteristics during ART were examined. A reduction of trait aggression, cognitive distortions, and social anxiety was observed. Neurocognitive characteristics were not associated with change in aggression, could not distinguish treatment completers from dropouts, and did not change after ART. It is suggested that new paradigms should be developed which take into account the social context in which these impairments appear.
攻击替代训练(ART)被广泛用于减少攻击行为,尽管也有不一致的结果,但它仍被认为是有效的。研究ART有效性的研究并未关注神经认知特征。关注这些方面将有助于增强对ART潜在机制的理解。当前的开放性非对照治疗研究评估了在法医精神病门诊患者的ART社交技能和愤怒控制模块中,神经认知特征是否与攻击行为的变化相关。此外,还研究了治疗退出者和完成者之间的差异以及ART期间这些特征的变化。观察到特质攻击、认知扭曲和社交焦虑有所减少。神经认知特征与攻击行为的变化无关,无法区分治疗完成者和退出者,并且在ART后没有变化。建议应开发新的范式,将这些损伤出现的社会背景考虑在内。