University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada.
J Interpers Violence. 2021 Jan;36(1-2):636-662. doi: 10.1177/0886260517729400. Epub 2017 Sep 6.
Rational choice theory proposes that spousal violence survivors engage in a cost-benefit analysis when determining whether to contact the police in the aftermath of violence. Feminist intersectional frameworks contend that the perceived costs and benefits of police intervention differ among survivors based on their intersecting social identities. Normative theory further posits that it is not solely individual factors but also social norms derived from one's neighborhood context that may be related to reporting practices. Consistent with these perspectives, this study assessed the association between spousal violence survivors' sociodemographic, violence, and neighborhood characteristics and (a) police contact, (b) pathways to police contact, (c) motivations for contacting the police, and (d) motivations for not contacting the police. Data were drawn from the 2009 Canadian General Social Survey-Victimization main file, and included male and female survivors ( = 890). Survivors most commonly contacted the police to stop the violence (89.4%) and most commonly did not contact the police because they did not believe it was important enough (35.3%). Results of multivariate regression analysis indicate that survivors who were visible minority, those who feared for their lives, and those who were injured were significantly more likely to self-report violence to police. Survivors were more likely to say the violence was not important enough to report if there was a police station in their neighborhood, and were less likely to say that violence was not important enough to report if they had experienced multiple incidents of violence. Implications for policing and criminal justice system engagement with spousal violence survivors are provided.
理性选择理论提出,在暴力发生后,配偶暴力幸存者会进行成本效益分析,以决定是否联系警方。女权主义交叉框架认为,根据幸存者的交叉社会身份,警察干预的感知成本和收益有所不同。规范理论进一步假设,与报告实践相关的不仅是个人因素,还有来自其邻里环境的社会规范。本研究根据这些观点,评估了配偶暴力幸存者的社会人口统计学、暴力和邻里特征与 (a) 与警方联系、(b) 与警方联系的途径、(c) 联系警方的动机和 (d) 不与警方联系的动机之间的关联。数据来自 2009 年加拿大综合社会调查-受害者主要档案,包括男性和女性幸存者 (=890)。幸存者最常联系警方是为了制止暴力(89.4%),最常不联系警方是因为他们认为这不够重要(35.3%)。多元回归分析的结果表明,少数族裔幸存者、那些担心自己生命安全的幸存者和那些受伤的幸存者更有可能向警方报告暴力行为。如果邻里有警察局,幸存者更有可能说暴力行为不够重要而无需报告,而如果他们经历过多次暴力事件,他们则不太可能说暴力行为不够重要而无需报告。为与配偶暴力幸存者接触的警务和刑事司法系统提供了启示。