Heineman E F, Shy C M, Checkoway H
Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
Am J Ind Med. 1989;15(3):267-82. doi: 10.1002/ajim.4700150304.
This case-control study within a metropolitan fire department evaluated the effect of self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA) and other risk factors on three types of injury at the scene of a fire (smoke inhalation, burns, and falls). Data on 75 injured fire fighters and 144 controls came from telephone interviews and department records. The two sets of uninjured fire-fighter controls were matched to cases on incident (n = 72) or on job position and fire type and size (n = 72). Smoke inhalation cases were not significantly different from controls in SCBA use, cigarette smoking, previous fires in the shift, or injury history. Jobs with high risk of burns included nozzle operator, engine officer, and forcible-entry person in first-due companies (OR = 20.1). Other risk factors for burns were: basement origin of fire (OR = 10.2); prior fire-fighting training outside the present department (same fire: OR = 11.2; similar fire: OR = 3.9); and on-duty injury in the prior 12 months (same fire: OR = 4.3; similar fire: OR = 3.5). When other risk factors were considered, consistent SCBA use was associated with falls (same fire: OR = 11.8; similar fire: OR = 4.3) but not with burns. Risk of falls also was elevated among members of truck companies (OR = 17.7) and fire fighters without children (same fire: OR = 8.4; similar fire: OR = 7.4). On-duty injury in the past 12 months was associated with falls when one compared cases with similar-fire controls (OR = 5.5), but not with controls attending the same fire. Neither age nor experience was related to injury in this population.
这项在一个大城市消防部门开展的病例对照研究,评估了自给式呼吸器(SCBA)及其他风险因素对火灾现场三种类型伤害(吸入烟雾、烧伤和跌倒)的影响。75名受伤消防员和144名对照的数据来自电话访谈和部门记录。两组未受伤的消防员对照在事件(n = 72)或工作岗位、火灾类型和规模(n = 72)方面与病例进行匹配。在使用SCBA、吸烟、当班期间之前发生的火灾或受伤史方面,吸入烟雾的病例与对照无显著差异。烧伤风险高的工作包括首批到达公司的水枪操作员、消防车指挥员和强行进入人员(比值比[OR]=20.1)。烧伤的其他风险因素包括:火灾起源于地下室(OR = 10.2);在当前部门之外接受过先前的消防培训(同一火灾:OR = 11.2;类似火灾:OR = 3.9);以及在过去12个月内有当班受伤情况(同一火灾:OR = 4.3;类似火灾:OR = 3.5)。在考虑其他风险因素时,持续使用SCBA与跌倒相关(同一火灾:OR = 11.8;类似火灾:OR = 4.3),但与烧伤无关。云梯车公司成员中跌倒风险也升高(OR = 17.7),没有孩子的消防员中跌倒风险也升高(同一火灾:OR = 8.4;类似火灾:OR = 7.4)。在将病例与类似火灾的对照进行比较时,过去12个月内的当班受伤与跌倒相关(OR = 5.5),但与参与同一火灾的对照无关。在该人群中,年龄和经验均与受伤无关。