Wekesa Eliud, Askew Ian, Abuya Timothy
School of Humanities and Social Sciences, South Eastern Kenya University, Kitui, Kenya.
Department of Reproductive Health, Population Council, Nairobi, Kenya.
PLoS One. 2018 Jan 9;13(1):e0190473. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0190473. eCollection 2018.
Ambivalence in pregnancy intentions is well-documented in sub-Saharan African (SSA) settings and has been associated with inconsistent use of contraception, thereby exposing women using contraception to the possibility of unintended pregnancies. A better understanding of the potential role for client counseling interventions in enabling women to achieve their pregnancy intentions is essential for aiding program efforts to reduce unintended pregnancies.
To measure ambivalence in pregnancy intentions longitudinally and determine its association with the quality of care received, controlling for demographic, socio-economic and contextual factors among a cohort of family planning (FP) clients in Kenya.
This paper uses data drawn from a prospective cohort study of FP clients to investigate the relationship between the quality of care received during FP service delivery and the decisiveness of their pregnancy intentions over time. The study tests the hypothesis that higher quality of care enables women to be less ambivalent about their pregnancy intentions. Binary logistic regression with random effects and multinomial logistic regression were used to assess the predictive effect of the quality of care received by a woman on the decisiveness or ambivalence of her pregnancy intentions, and on any shifts in ambivalence over time, controlling for background characteristics. The study recruited 1,957 women aged 15-49 years attending twelve family planning clinics in four counties in Central Kenya; of these, 1,053 women were observed for four rounds of data collection over a period of 24 months and form the sample for analysis.
A substantial proportion (43%) of women expressed ambivalence about their intentions to become pregnant at some point during the study period, while over half (57%) remained unequivocal throughout the study. Almost one third of women (31%) shifted from being unequivocal to ambivalent and 12% shifted from ambivalence to being unequivocal. Women experiencing higher quality of care have lower odds of ever expressing ambivalence and higher odds of remaining unequivocal over time, net of other factors. Quality of care was not associated with a shift in ambivalence over time.
FP programs offering higher quality of care are likely to support women to be more decisive in their pregnancy intentions. Improving the quality of care can contribute to reduced ambivalence and consequently reduced likelihood of unintended pregnancy among contraceptive users. This study provides further evidence of the benefits gained through providing high quality services.
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01694862.
在撒哈拉以南非洲地区,怀孕意愿的矛盾心理有充分记录,且与避孕措施的不一致使用有关,从而使使用避孕措施的女性面临意外怀孕的可能性。更好地理解客户咨询干预措施在帮助女性实现怀孕意愿方面的潜在作用,对于协助减少意外怀孕的项目努力至关重要。
纵向测量怀孕意愿的矛盾心理,并确定其与所接受护理质量的关联,同时控制肯尼亚一组计划生育客户的人口统计学、社会经济和背景因素。
本文使用来自一项计划生育客户前瞻性队列研究的数据,以调查计划生育服务提供期间所接受护理质量与她们怀孕意愿的决定性随时间变化之间的关系。该研究检验了这样一个假设,即更高质量的护理能使女性对其怀孕意愿的矛盾心理减少。使用具有随机效应的二元逻辑回归和多项逻辑回归来评估女性所接受护理质量对其怀孕意愿的决定性或矛盾心理以及随时间矛盾心理的任何变化的预测作用,并控制背景特征。该研究招募了1957名年龄在15至49岁之间、在肯尼亚中部四个县的12家计划生育诊所就诊的女性;其中,1053名女性在24个月的时间里接受了四轮数据收集,并构成分析样本。
在研究期间的某个时间点,相当一部分(43%)女性对怀孕意愿表达了矛盾心理,而超过一半(57%)的女性在整个研究过程中态度始终明确。近三分之一(31%)的女性从态度明确转变为矛盾,12%的女性从矛盾转变为态度明确。在排除其他因素后,接受更高质量护理的女性表达矛盾心理的几率更低,随着时间推移态度始终明确的几率更高。护理质量与矛盾心理随时间的变化无关。
提供更高质量护理的计划生育项目可能会支持女性在怀孕意愿上更加果断。提高护理质量有助于减少矛盾心理,从而降低避孕使用者意外怀孕的可能性。本研究进一步证明了提供高质量服务所带来的益处。
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01694862