de Jong Irja Marije, Kupper Frank, Broerse Jacqueline
Athena Institute, VU University Amsterdam, De Boelelaan 1085, 1081 HV, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Life Sci Soc Policy. 2018 Jan 24;14(1):2. doi: 10.1186/s40504-018-0066-1.
Emerging RRI practices have goals with respect to learning, governance and achieving RRI outcomes (action). However, few practices actually achieve the action phase as actors lack room to manoeuvre, and lack guidance on how to move forward because of the inherent unscriptedness of the emerging RRI practice. In this explorative research an emerging RRI practice is studied to identify factors and barriers to the creation of adaptive space, in which actors can be responsive to the other and adapt, and a narrative can be created in the act of doing. This paper describes how formal and informal ways of organizing emerging RRI practices contribute to adaptive space, and how the metaphorical heuristic of improvisational theatre provides clear action principles to actors involved in emerging RRI practices in action. The RRI practice studied here lies in the domain of juvenile justice, where barriers that restrict room to manoeuvre are abundant. Five factors - 'informality over formality', 'shared action space', 'be flexible', 'keep the action moving' and 'put the relationship central' - were identified to facilitate reflexivity and adaptation in this space.
新兴的负责任研究与创新(RRI)实践在学习、治理和实现RRI成果(行动)方面都有目标。然而,由于参与者缺乏行动空间,且新兴的RRI实践具有内在的非预设性,缺乏如何推进的指导,很少有实践能真正进入行动阶段。在这项探索性研究中,对一种新兴的RRI实践进行了研究,以确定创造适应性空间的因素和障碍,在这个空间中参与者能够相互响应并进行调整,并且在实践过程中能够形成一种叙事。本文描述了组织新兴RRI实践的正式和非正式方式如何促成适应性空间,以及即兴戏剧的隐喻启发如何为参与新兴RRI实践的行动者提供明确的行动原则。这里所研究的RRI实践处于青少年司法领域,在该领域限制行动空间的障碍众多。研究确定了五个因素——“非正式高于正式”、“共享行动空间”、“保持灵活性”、“推动行动进行”以及“将关系置于中心”——以促进该空间中的反思性和适应性。