Davies Anna R, Edwards Ferne, Marovelli Brigida, Morrow Oona, Rut Monika, Weymes Marion
Department of Geography School of Natural Sciences Trinity College Dublin Dublin Ireland.
Area (Oxf). 2017 Dec;49(4):510-518. doi: 10.1111/area.12340. Epub 2017 Apr 26.
Activities utilising online tools are an increasingly visible part of our everyday lives, providing new subjects, objects and relationships - essentially new landscapes - for research, as well as new conceptual and methodological challenges for researchers. In parallel, calls for collaborative interdisciplinary, even transdisciplinary, research are increasing. Yet practical guidance and critical reflection on the challenges and opportunities of conducting collaborative research online, particularly in emergent areas, is limited. In response, this paper details what we term the 'creative construction' involved in a collaborative project building an exploratory database of more than 4000 food sharing activities in 100 cities that utilise internet and digital technologies in some way (ICT mediated for brevity) to pursue their goals. The research was undertaken by an international team of researchers, including geographers, which utilised a combination of reflexive coding and online collaboration to develop a system for exploring the practice and performance of ICT-mediated food sharing in cities. This paper will unpack the black box of using the internet as a source of data about emergent practices and provide critical reflection on that highly negotiated and essentially handcrafted process. While the substance of the paper focuses on the under-determined realm of food sharing, a site where it is claimed that ICT is transforming practices, the issues raised have resonance far beyond the specificities of this particular endeavour. While challenging, we argue that handcrafting systems for navigating emergent online data is vital, not least to render visible the complexities and contestations around definition, categorisation and translation.
利用在线工具的活动在我们的日常生活中越来越常见,为研究提供了新的主题、对象和关系——本质上是新的领域——同时也给研究人员带来了新的概念和方法挑战。与此同时,对跨学科甚至跨领域合作研究的需求也在增加。然而,对于在线开展合作研究的挑战和机遇,尤其是在新兴领域,实际指导和批判性反思却很有限。作为回应,本文详细阐述了我们所说的一个合作项目中的“创造性构建”,该项目构建了一个探索性数据库,涵盖100个城市中4000多项食物共享活动,这些活动以某种方式利用互联网和数字技术(为简洁起见简称信息通信技术介导)来实现其目标。该研究由一个包括地理学家在内的国际研究团队进行,他们利用反思性编码和在线协作相结合的方式,开发了一个系统,用于探索城市中信息通信技术介导的食物共享的实践和表现。本文将打开把互联网作为新兴实践数据来源的“黑匣子”,并对这个经过高度协商且本质上是手工制作的过程进行批判性反思。虽然本文的实质内容聚焦于食物共享这个尚未明确界定的领域,即一个声称信息通信技术正在改变实践的领域,但所提出的问题远远超出了这一特定研究的具体情况。尽管具有挑战性,但我们认为,手工制作用于处理新兴在线数据的系统至关重要,尤其是要使围绕定义、分类和翻译的复杂性和争议性变得可见。