Mählmann Laura, Schee Gen Halfmann Sebastian, von Wyl Agnes, Brand Angela
Psychiatric Clinics of the University of Basel, Centre for Affective, Stress, and Sleep Disorders, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland.
United Nations University - Maastricht Economic and Social Research Institute on Innovation and Technology (UNU-MERIT), Maastricht University, Maastricht, the Netherlands.
Public Health Genomics. 2017;20(5):293-306. doi: 10.1159/000486588. Epub 2018 Feb 7.
To assess the willingness of older Swiss adults to share genetic data for research purposes and to investigate factors that might impact their willingness to share data.
Semi-structured interviews were conducted among 40 participants (19 male and 21 female) aged between 67 and 92 years, between December 2013 and April 2014 attending the Seniorenuniversität Zürich, Switzerland. All interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and anonymized. For the analysis of the interviews, an initial coding scheme was developed, refined over time, and applied afterwards to all interviews.
The majority of participants were in favor of placing genetic data to research's disposal. Participant's motivations to share data were mainly driven by altruistic reasons and by contributing to the greater good. Furthermore, several factors which might impact the willingness to share data such as sharing data with private companies, generational differences, differences between sharing genetic data or health data, and sharing due to financial incentives were highlighted. Last, some participants indicated concerns regarding data sharing such as misuse of data, the fear of becoming a transparent citizen, and data safety. However, 20% of the participants express confidence in data protection. Even participants who were skeptical in the beginning of the interviews admitted the benefits of data sharing.
Overall, this study suggests older citizens are willing to share their data for research purposes. However, most of them will only contribute if their data is appropriately protected and if they trust the research institution to use the shared data responsibly. More transparency and detailed information regarding the data usage are urgently needed. There is a great need to increase the engagement of older adults in research since they present a large segment of our society - one which is often underexamined in research.
Increased focus on general public engagement, especially of older adults, in scientific research activities known as "citizen science" is needed to further strengthen the uptake of personalized medicine.
评估瑞士老年成年人出于研究目的分享基因数据的意愿,并调查可能影响其数据分享意愿的因素。
2013年12月至2014年4月期间,对40名年龄在67至92岁之间、参加瑞士苏黎世老年大学的参与者(19名男性和21名女性)进行了半结构化访谈。所有访谈均进行了录音、逐字转录并匿名化处理。为了分析访谈内容,制定了一个初始编码方案,随着时间的推移进行了完善,随后应用于所有访谈。
大多数参与者赞成将基因数据用于研究。参与者分享数据的动机主要是出于利他主义原因以及为更大的利益做出贡献。此外,还强调了几个可能影响数据分享意愿的因素,如与私人公司分享数据、代际差异、分享基因数据或健康数据之间的差异以及因经济激励而分享。最后,一些参与者表示对数据分享存在担忧,如数据的不当使用、担心成为透明公民以及数据安全。然而,20%的参与者对数据保护表示有信心。即使在访谈开始时持怀疑态度的参与者也承认了数据分享的好处。
总体而言,本研究表明老年公民愿意出于研究目的分享他们的数据。然而,他们中的大多数人只有在数据得到适当保护且他们信任研究机构会负责任地使用共享数据时才会做出贡献。迫切需要更多关于数据使用的透明度和详细信息。由于老年人是我们社会的很大一部分——而这一群体在研究中往往未得到充分研究,因此非常有必要提高老年人参与研究的程度。
需要更多地关注公众,特别是老年人,参与被称为“公民科学”的科研活动,以进一步加强个性化医疗的应用。