Fang Jiaohui, Song Huali, Zhang Yiran, Li Yanran, Liu Jian
Institute of Environmental Research, Shandong University, Jinan, China.
Wendeng Meteorological Bureau, Weihai, China.
PLoS One. 2018 Feb 13;13(2):e0192727. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0192727. eCollection 2018.
Evaluation of ecosystem services has become a hotspot in terms of research focus, but uncertainties over appropriate methods remain. Evaluation can be based on the unit price of services (services value method) or the unit price of the area (area value method). The former takes meteorological factors into account, while the latter does not. This study uses Kunyu Mountain Nature Reserve as a study site at which to test the effects of climate on the ecosystem services. Measured data and remote sensing imagery processed in a geographic information system were combined to evaluate gas regulation and soil conservation, and the influence of meteorological factors on ecosystem services. Results were used to analyze the appropriateness of the area value method. Our results show that the value of ecosystem services is significantly affected by meteorological factors, especially precipitation. Use of the area value method (which ignores the impacts of meteorological factors) could considerably impede the accuracy of ecosystem services evaluation. Results were also compared with the valuation obtained using the modified equivalent value factor (MEVF) method, which is a modified area value method that considers changes in meteorological conditions. We found that MEVF still underestimates the value of ecosystem services, although it can reflect to some extent the annual variation in meteorological factors. Our findings contribute to increasing the accuracy of evaluation of ecosystem services.
生态系统服务评估已成为研究重点方面的一个热点,但在合适方法上仍存在不确定性。评估可基于服务单价(服务价值法)或面积单价(面积价值法)。前者考虑气象因素,而后者不考虑。本研究以昆嵛山自然保护区为研究地点,测试气候对生态系统服务的影响。将实测数据与在地理信息系统中处理的遥感影像相结合,以评估气体调节和土壤保持,以及气象因素对生态系统服务的影响。结果用于分析面积价值法的适用性。我们的结果表明,生态系统服务价值受气象因素显著影响,尤其是降水。使用面积价值法(忽略气象因素的影响)可能会严重阻碍生态系统服务评估的准确性。结果还与使用修正当量值因子(MEVF)法获得的估值进行了比较,MEVF法是一种考虑气象条件变化的修正面积价值法。我们发现,尽管MEVF法能在一定程度上反映气象因素的年变化,但它仍低估了生态系统服务的价值。我们的研究结果有助于提高生态系统服务评估的准确性。