1 RIDBC Renwick Centre, Royal Institute for Deaf and Blind Children/Macquarie University, Australia.
2 University of Newcastle Faculty of Education and Arts, Australia.
J Telemed Telecare. 2019 May;25(4):249-260. doi: 10.1177/1357633X18755883. Epub 2018 Feb 13.
The use of telepractice, a method of delivering services through telecommunications technologies that provides two-way, synchronous audio and video signals in real-time, is becoming increasingly commonplace in early childhood education and intervention for children who are deaf or hard of hearing. Although the use of telepractice has been validated in the health sector as a viable and effective alternative to in-person service provision, evidence to support its use in the delivery of family-centred early intervention is still emerging. The purpose of this scoping review was to describe the current use of telepractice in the delivery of family-centred early childhood intervention for children who are deaf or hard of hearing, and their families.
The review followed the framework outlined by the Joanna Briggs Institute (2015), including an iterative three-step search strategy. Specific inclusion criteria and data extraction fields were outlined in advance.
A total of 23 peer-reviewed publications were included in the review. Most publications (70%) provided anecdotal evidence of the challenges and benefits associated with telepractice. The remaining publications (30%) reported on research studies evaluating the effectiveness of early intervention delivered through telepractice. Of the 23 included papers, 18 viewed the use of telepractice positively while the remaining 5 reported mixed conclusions and the need for more data.
Current evidence in the literature indicates that telepractice can be an effective model for delivering family-centred early intervention for children who are deaf or hard of hearing. However, more research is needed to substantiate the use of telepractice as a viable alternative to traditional in-person services, rather than being seen as supplemental to such services.
远程实践是一种通过电信技术提供双向实时音频和视频信号的服务方法,在为聋儿和听障儿童提供早期教育和干预方面变得越来越普遍。虽然远程实践在卫生部门已被验证为一种可行且有效的替代传统面对面服务的方法,但支持其在家庭为中心的早期干预服务中的应用的证据仍在不断涌现。本综述的目的是描述远程实践在为聋儿和听障儿童及其家庭提供家庭为中心的早期儿童干预服务中的当前应用。
本综述遵循乔安娜·布里格斯研究所(2015 年)概述的框架,包括迭代三步搜索策略。事先概述了具体的纳入标准和数据提取字段。
共有 23 篇同行评议的出版物被纳入综述。大多数出版物(70%)提供了与远程实践相关的挑战和好处的轶事证据。其余出版物(30%)报告了评估通过远程实践提供的早期干预效果的研究。在 23 篇纳入的论文中,18 篇对远程实践的使用持肯定态度,而其余 5 篇报告了混合结论,并需要更多数据。
文献中的现有证据表明,远程实践可以是为聋儿和听障儿童提供家庭为中心的早期干预的有效模式。然而,需要更多的研究来证实远程实践作为传统面对面服务的可行替代方案的使用,而不仅仅是将其视为此类服务的补充。