School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
Disabil Rehabil Assist Technol. 2023 Nov;18(8):1508-1521. doi: 10.1080/17483107.2022.2048098. Epub 2022 Mar 14.
This review aimed to (1) describe the nature of engagement in telepractice early intervention (EI) for families of young children with developmental disabilities; and (2) identify major barriers and facilitators for developing and maintaining engagement telepractice.
A qualitative systematic review was conducted, searching systematically across six databases (i.e., PUBMED, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Web of Science, EMBASE, and Scopus). The search identified 14 studies which met the inclusion criteria of peer-reviewed studies exploring EI professionals', families', managers', or service's views of engagement in telepractice EI using qualitative methodologies. The studies were appraised using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme and data were analysed using thematic synthesis.
The synthesised data were grouped into four main themes reflecting the nuances of engagement in telepractice EI: (1) children and family engagement is facilitated and enhanced during telepractice interaction; (2) engagement may enhance therapy outcomes through telepractice multidisciplinary collaboration and communication; (3) there are challenges to engagement in the telepractice environment; and (4) preparation in telepractice can improve the development of engagement.
This review provides a comprehensive characterisation of engagement and describes a set of conceptual recommendations for establishing and maintaining engagement when using telepractice in EI.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATIONBuilding and maintaining engagement with families of young children with developmental disability/delay through telepractice is feasible.Despite some similarities between in-person and telepractice engagement, there are certain unique features of telepractice engagement that professionals and families may need to consider while providing/receiving early intervention services remotely.Preparation and training on how to engage in telepractice is recommended for professionals and families of young children with developmental disability/delay.Understanding how professionals and families engage with one another during telepractice interactions may improve targeted child and family intervention outcomes.
本综述旨在:(1)描述早期干预(EI)中针对发育障碍幼儿家庭的远程实践参与的性质;以及 (2)确定发展和维持远程实践参与的主要障碍和促进因素。
进行了定性系统评价,在六个数据库(即 PUBMED、CINAHL、PsycINFO、Web of Science、EMBASE 和 Scopus)中系统地进行了搜索。该搜索确定了 14 项符合纳入标准的研究,这些研究使用定性方法探讨了 EI 专业人员、家庭、管理者或服务提供者对远程实践 EI 参与的看法。使用批判性评估技能计划对研究进行评估,并使用主题合成分析数据。
综合数据分为四个主要主题,反映了远程实践 EI 中参与的细微差别:(1) 儿童和家庭的参与在远程实践互动中得到促进和增强;(2) 参与可能通过远程实践多学科合作和沟通来增强治疗效果;(3) 远程实践环境中存在参与挑战;以及 (4) 远程实践准备可以改善参与的发展。
本综述全面描述了参与,并提出了一套关于在 EI 中使用远程实践时建立和维持参与的概念性建议。
通过远程实践与发育障碍/延迟的幼儿家庭建立和维持参与是可行的。尽管远程实践和面对面实践的参与有一些相似之处,但远程实践参与有一些独特的特点,专业人员和家庭在远程提供/接受早期干预服务时可能需要考虑。建议为发育障碍/延迟的幼儿的专业人员和家庭提供有关如何参与远程实践的准备和培训。了解专业人员和家庭在远程实践互动中如何相互参与,可能会提高针对儿童和家庭的干预效果。