Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 08544, USA.
Wildlife Conservation Society, 2300 Bronx Blvd, New York, USA.
Sci Rep. 2018 Feb 16;8(1):3143. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-21401-1.
Coffee is a major tropical commodity crop that can provide supplementary habitat for native wildlife. In Asia, coffee production is an increasingly important driver of landscape transformation and shifts between different coffee species is a major dimension of agroforestry trends. Yet few studies have compared the ecological impacts of conversion between different coffee species. We evaluated whether or not the two species of coffee grown globally-Coffea arabica and C. canephora (denoted "robusta")-had equivalent avian conservation value in the Western Ghats, India, where robusta production has become increasingly dominant. We found that habitat specialist and functional guild diversity was higher in arabica, and that arabica was more profitable. However, robusta farms generally supported the same or slightly higher abundances of habitat specialists and functional guilds, largely due to dense canopy and landscape-level forest cover. Farming practices, chiefly pesticide use, may affect the suitability of coffee agroforests as habitat for avian specialists, and at present, robusta farmers tended to use less pesticide. Given future projections for arabica to robusta conversion in tropical Asia, our study indicates that certification efforts should prioritize maintaining native canopy shade trees and forest cover to ensure that coffee landscapes can continue providing biodiversity benefits.
咖啡是一种主要的热带商品作物,可以为本地野生动物提供补充栖息地。在亚洲,咖啡生产是景观转型的一个日益重要的驱动因素,不同咖啡物种之间的转变是农业林业趋势的一个主要方面。然而,很少有研究比较不同咖啡物种之间转化的生态影响。我们评估了在印度西高止山脉,全球种植的两种咖啡——阿拉伯咖啡(Coffea arabica)和罗布斯塔咖啡(C. canephora,称为“罗布斯塔”)——是否具有同等的鸟类保护价值,因为罗布斯塔的产量在该地区变得越来越占主导地位。我们发现,在阿拉伯咖啡中,栖息地专家和功能群多样性更高,而且阿拉伯咖啡更有利可图。然而,罗布斯塔农场通常支持相同或略高的栖息地专家和功能群的丰度,这主要是由于茂密的树冠和景观级别的森林覆盖。农业实践,主要是农药的使用,可能会影响咖啡农林作为鸟类专家栖息地的适宜性,而目前,罗布斯塔农民倾向于使用较少的农药。考虑到未来在热带亚洲阿拉伯咖啡向罗布斯塔咖啡的转换预测,我们的研究表明,认证工作应优先考虑保持本地树冠遮荫树和森林覆盖,以确保咖啡景观能够继续提供生物多样性效益。