Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Herlev University Hospital, Herlev, Denmark.
Department of Clinical Medicine, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2018 Apr;97(4):417-423. doi: 10.1111/aogs.13330.
Information bias occurs when any information used in a study is either measured or recorded inaccurately. This paper describes some of the most common types of information bias, using examples from obstetrics and gynecology, and describes how information bias may affect results of observational studies. Non-differential misclassification occurs when the degree of misclassification of exposure status among those with and those without the disease is the same; in cohort studies, this type of bias is most likely and will bias estimates toward no association when exposure is dichotomized. Non-differential underreporting of an exposure with more than two categories may mask a true threshold effect as a dose-response relation and, if a true threshold effect exists, the threshold will be set at too low a level, if the exposure is underreported. Differential misclassification may cause bias in either direction and is particularly likely, when exposure status is reported after the outcome occurred. Misclassification of confounders is an issue that needs special attention by researchers, as failure to measure accurately one or more (strong) confounders may seriously bias the observed results. Misclassification of disease status may also cause bias of estimates of association in either direction. Information bias is probably best prevented during planning of data collection, as there are few and insufficient methods available for correcting inaccurate information.
信息偏倚是指在研究中使用的任何信息都存在不准确的测量或记录。本文通过妇产科的实例,介绍了一些最常见的信息偏倚类型,并描述了信息偏倚如何影响观察性研究的结果。非差异性错误分类是指在有疾病和无疾病的人群中,暴露状态的错误分类程度相同;在队列研究中,这种类型的偏倚最有可能发生,并且当暴露状态被二分类时,会导致估计值向无关联偏倚。对于具有两个以上类别的暴露,非差异性少报可能会掩盖真实的阈值效应,而作为剂量-反应关系,如果存在真实的阈值效应,那么如果暴露被少报,则阈值将设置在过低的水平。差异性错误分类可能会导致偏倚向任何方向发展,尤其是在暴露状态在结果发生后报告时。混杂因素的错误分类是研究人员需要特别关注的问题,因为未能准确测量一个或多个(强)混杂因素可能会严重偏倚观察结果。疾病状态的错误分类也可能导致关联估计值的偏倚向任何方向发展。信息偏倚最好在数据收集的规划阶段进行预防,因为目前可用的纠正不准确信息的方法很少且不够充分。