Lima de Miranda Katharina, Neyse Levent, Schmidt Ulrich
Kiel Institute for the World EconomyKiel, Germany.
SOEP at German Institute for Economic Research (DIW)Berlin, Germany.
Front Behav Neurosci. 2018 Feb 1;12:9. doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2018.00009. eCollection 2018.
Prenatal androgen exposure affects the brain development of the fetus which may facilitate certain behaviors and decision patterns in the later life. The ratio between the lengths of second and the fourth fingers (2D:4D) is a negative biomarker of the ratio between prenatal androgen and estrogen exposure and men typically have lower ratios than women. In line with the typical findings suggesting that women are more risk averse than men, several studies have also shown negative relationships between 2D:4D and risk taking although the evidence is not conclusive. Previous studies have also reported that both men and women believe women are more risk averse than men. In the current study, we re-test the relationship between 2D:4D and risk preferences in a German student sample and also investigate whether the 2D:4D ratio is associated with people's perceptions about others' risk preferences. Following an incentivized risk elicitation task, we asked all participants their predictions about (i) others' responses (without sex specification), (ii) men's responses, and (iii) women's responses; then measured their 2D:4D ratios. In line with the previous findings, female participants in our sample were more risk averse. While both men and women underestimated other participants' (non sex-specific) and women's risky decisions on average, their predictions about men were accurate. We also found evidence for the false consensus effect, as risky choices are positively correlated with predictions about other participants' risky choices. The 2D:4D ratio was not directly associated either with risk preferences or the predictions of other participants' choices. An unexpected finding was that women with mid-range levels of 2D:4D estimated significantly larger sex differences in participants' decisions. This finding needs further testing in future studies.
产前雄激素暴露会影响胎儿的大脑发育,这可能会在日后促成某些行为和决策模式。食指与无名指长度之比(2D:4D)是产前雄激素与雌激素暴露比例的一个负向生物标志物,男性的这一比例通常低于女性。与表明女性比男性更厌恶风险的典型研究结果一致,一些研究也显示2D:4D与冒险行为之间存在负相关关系,尽管证据并不确凿。此前的研究还报告称,男性和女性都认为女性比男性更厌恶风险。在本研究中,我们在一个德国学生样本中重新检验了2D:4D与风险偏好之间的关系,并调查了2D:4D比例是否与人们对他人风险偏好的认知有关。在一项有激励措施的风险诱导任务之后,我们询问所有参与者对以下方面的预测:(i)他人的反应(未指明性别)、(ii)男性的反应以及(iii)女性的反应;然后测量他们的2D:4D比例。与之前的研究结果一致,我们样本中的女性参与者更厌恶风险。虽然男性和女性平均都低估了其他参与者(未指明性别)和女性的冒险决策,但他们对男性的预测是准确的。我们还发现了错误共识效应的证据,因为冒险选择与对其他参与者冒险选择的预测呈正相关。2D:4D比例与风险偏好或对其他参与者选择的预测均无直接关联。一个意外发现是,2D:4D处于中等水平的女性估计参与者决策中的性别差异显著更大。这一发现需要在未来的研究中进一步验证。