Lampropoulou Sofia I, Billis Evdokia, Gedikoglou Ingrid A, Michailidou Christina, Nowicky Alexander V, Skrinou Dimitra, Michailidi Fotini, Chandrinou Danae, Meligkoni Margarita
a Department of Physical Therapy, School of Health and Welfare Professions , ΤΕΙ of Western Greece , Aigio , Greece.
b Physiotherapy Program, Department of Life and Health Sciences , University of Nicosia , Cyprus.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2019 Feb;35(2):171-182. doi: 10.1080/09593985.2018.1441931. Epub 2018 Feb 23.
This study aimed to investigate the psychometric characteristics of reliability, validity and ability to detect change of a newly developed balance assessment tool, the Mini-BESTest, in Greek patients with stroke.
A prospective, observational design study with test-retest measures was conducted.
A convenience sample of 21 Greek patients with chronic stroke (14 male, 7 female; age of 63 ± 16 years) was recruited. Two independent examiners administered the scale, for the inter-rater reliability, twice within 10 days for the test-retest reliability. Bland Altman Analysis for repeated measures assessed the absolute reliability and the Standard Error of Measurement (SEM) and the Minimum Detectable Change at 95% confidence interval (MDC) were established. The Greek Mini-BESTest (Mini-BESTest) was correlated with the Greek Berg Balance Scale (BBS) for assessing the concurrent validity and with the Timed Up and Go (TUG), the Functional Reach Test (FRT) and the Greek Falls Efficacy Scale-International (FES-I) for the convergent validity.
The Mini-BESTestGR demonstrated excellent inter-rater reliability (ICC (95%CI) = 0.997 (0.995-0.999, SEM = 0.46) with the scores of two raters within the limits of agreement (mean = -0.143 ± 0.727, p > 0.05) and test-retest reliability (ICC (95%CI) = 0.966 (0.926-0.988), SEM = 1.53). Additionally, the Mini-BESTest yielded very strong to moderate correlations with BBS (r = 0.924, p < 0.001), TUG (r = -0.823, p < 0.001), FES-I (r = -0.734, p < 0.001) and FRT (r = 0.689, p < 0.001). MDC was 4.25 points.
The exceptionally high reliability and the equally good validity of the Mini-BESTest, strongly support its utility in Greek people with chronic stroke. Its ability to identify clinically meaningful changes and falls risk need further investigation.
本研究旨在调查一种新开发的平衡评估工具——简易平衡评估系统测试(Mini-BESTest)在希腊中风患者中的信度、效度及检测变化的能力等心理测量学特征。
采用前瞻性观察设计研究,并进行重测。
招募了21名希腊慢性中风患者(14名男性,7名女性;年龄63±16岁)的便利样本。两名独立检查者进行量表施测,以评估评分者间信度,在10天内进行两次施测以评估重测信度。采用Bland Altman重复测量分析评估绝对信度,并确定测量标准误(SEM)和95%置信区间的最小可检测变化(MDC)。将希腊版简易平衡评估系统测试(Mini-BESTest)与希腊版伯格平衡量表(BBS)进行相关性分析以评估同时效度,与计时起立行走测试(TUG)、功能性前伸测试(FRT)和希腊版国际跌倒效能量表(FES-I)进行相关性分析以评估聚合效度。
希腊版简易平衡评估系统测试(Mini-BESTestGR)显示出极好的评分者间信度(组内相关系数(ICC,95%置信区间)=0.997(0.995 - 0.999),SEM = 0.46),两名评分者的分数在一致性界限内(均值=-0.143±0.727,p>0.05),重测信度也较好(ICC(95%置信区间)=0.966(0.926 - 0.988),SEM = 1.53)。此外,简易平衡评估系统测试与伯格平衡量表(r = 0.924,p<0.001)、计时起立行走测试(r = -0.823,p<0.001)、国际跌倒效能量表(r = -0.734,p<0.001)和功能性前伸测试(r = 0.689,p<0.001)之间具有非常强到中等程度的相关性。MDC为4.25分。
简易平衡评估系统测试具有极高的信度和同样良好的效度,有力地支持了其在希腊慢性中风患者中的实用性。其识别临床有意义变化和跌倒风险的能力有待进一步研究。