Gordon F. Derner School of Psychology, Adelphi University, Garden City, NY.
J Clin Psychol. 2018 May;74(5):779-787. doi: 10.1002/jclp.22609. Epub 2018 Mar 14.
The primary aim of this study was to investigate the effects of the 2016 United States presidential election and ensuing political climate on patients' experiences in psychotherapy. A sample of 604 self-described Democrat and Republican patients from 50 states participated in the study. Results showed that most therapists disclosed their political stance (explicitly or implicitly) and most patients discussed politics with their therapists. 64% of Clinton supporters and 38% of Trump supporters assumed political similarity with their therapist. Stronger patient-reported alliance levels were found for patients who (a) perceived political similarity; (b) reported implicit therapist political disclosure; and (c) found in-session political discussions helpful. Additionally, Clinton (but not Trump) supporters reported significant pre-post-election decreases in expression of positive emotions and increases in both expression of negative emotions and engagement in discussions about socio-political topics. Our findings suggest that the current political climate infiltrates the therapeutic space and affects therapeutic process and content.
本研究的主要目的是探讨 2016 年美国总统选举及随后的政治氛围对患者接受心理治疗体验的影响。研究共纳入了来自 50 个州的 604 名自称为民主党人和共和党人的患者。结果显示,大多数治疗师(明确或含蓄地)透露了自己的政治立场,大多数患者与治疗师讨论过政治。64%的克林顿支持者和 38%的特朗普支持者认为自己与治疗师有相似的政治立场。患者报告的联盟水平越高,他们(a)感知到政治相似性;(b)报告治疗师的隐性政治披露;以及(c)认为治疗中讨论政治问题有帮助。此外,克林顿(而非特朗普)的支持者报告说,在选举前后,他们表达积极情绪的次数显著减少,表达消极情绪的次数和参与讨论社会政治话题的次数都有所增加。我们的研究结果表明,当前的政治氛围渗透到了治疗空间,影响了治疗过程和内容。