Istre Olav, Snejbjerg Dorthe
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology South Danish University, Odense, Denmark, and Aleris Hamlet Private Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Aleris Hamlet Private Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark.
JSLS. 2018 Jan-Mar;22(1). doi: 10.4293/JSLS.2017.00078.
After the U. S. Food and Drug Administration's recommendation against the use of power morcellation for tissue extraction in minimally invasive hysterectomy, the number of procedures completed laparoscopically declined in favor of open surgery laparotomy. We conducted a retrospective cohort study comparing perioperative and long-term outcomes, including complications associated with laparoscopic hysterectomy before and after the FDA recommendation.
We included procedures performed in Danish government hospitals (GHs) and a hospital specializing in minimally invasive gynecological surgery (MIGS). Different types of hysterectomy over the period from January 2011 through May 2016 were examined.
Hysterectomies were analyzed from GHs (n = 21,495) and from a hospital specializing in MIGS (n = 749). In the GHs, we found a decrease in open hysterectomy from 40% in 2011 to 20% in 2016. In the MIGS hospital, 4 of 749 (0.05%) open hysterectomies were performed during the 6 years; however, there was a change in operative technique. After the FDA recommendation, there was a shift from laparoscopic subtotal hysterectomy (LSH) to total laparoscopic hysterectomy (TLH) from 32% in 2011 to 82% by May 2016. Containment bags were used in LSH and large-uterus TLH after the 2014 advisory. Significantly more complications occurred in the GHs than in the MIGS hospital: 3224/21,495 (15%) vs 53/749 (7.0%), respectively.
The rate of minimally invasive hysterectomies continues to increase. However, after 2014, many of the morcellation techniques have been replaced by a minilaparotomy to extract the uterus at the end of surgery, compared to the use of the contained morcellation in 100% of cases in the MIGS hospital. There was a major difference in complication rates between the hospitals that is partly explainable by the challenge in training residents and the low operative volume of surgeons in GHs.
在美国食品药品监督管理局建议不要在微创子宫切除术中使用动力旋切术进行组织提取后,腹腔镜完成的手术数量下降,转而倾向于开放性剖腹手术。我们进行了一项回顾性队列研究,比较了围手术期和长期结局,包括美国食品药品监督管理局建议前后与腹腔镜子宫切除术相关的并发症。
我们纳入了在丹麦政府医院(GHs)和一家专门从事微创妇科手术(MIGS)的医院所进行的手术。对2011年1月至2016年5月期间不同类型的子宫切除术进行了检查。
分析了来自GHs(n = 21,495)和一家专门从事MIGS的医院(n = 749)的子宫切除术。在GHs中,我们发现开放性子宫切除术的比例从2011年的40%下降到2016年的20%。在MIGS医院,749例(0.05%)开放性子宫切除术中在6年期间进行了4例;然而,手术技术发生了变化。在美国食品药品监督管理局建议后,从腹腔镜次全子宫切除术(LSH)转变为全腹腔镜子宫切除术(TLH),从2011年的32%到2016年5月时达到82%。2014年咨询后,在LSH和大子宫TLH中使用了 containment bags。GHs中发生的并发症明显多于MIGS医院:分别为3224/21,495(15%)和53/749(7.0%)。
微创子宫切除术的比例持续上升。然而,2014年后,许多旋切技术已被小剖腹术取代,以便在手术结束时取出子宫,而在MIGS医院100%的病例中使用了 containment morcellation。医院之间的并发症发生率存在重大差异,部分原因可解释为GHs中住院医师培训的挑战和外科医生的低手术量。