Boughton Stephanie L, Kowalczuk Maria K, Meerpohl Joerg J, Wager Elizabeth, Moylan Elizabeth C
Springer Nature, 4 Crinan Street, London, N1 9XW UK.
2Institute for Evidence in Medicine (for Cochrane Germany Foundation), Medical Center - University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany.
Res Integr Peer Rev. 2018 Mar 6;3:3. doi: 10.1186/s41073-018-0047-1. eCollection 2018.
In May 2016, we launched , an international, open access journal with fully open peer review (reviewers are identified on their reports and named reports are published alongside the article) to provide a home for research on research and publication ethics, research reporting, and research on peer review. As the journal enters its third year, we reflect on recent events and highlights for the journal and explore how the journal is faring in terms of gender and diversity in peer review. We also share the particular interests of our Editors-in-Chief regarding models of peer review, reporting quality, common research integrity issues that arise during the publishing process, and how people interact with the published literature. We continue to encourage further research into peer review, research and publication ethics and research reporting, as we believe that all new initiatives should be evidence-based. We also remain open to constructive discussions of the developments in the field that offer new solutions.
2016年5月,我们推出了一本国际开放获取期刊,采用完全开放的同行评审(评审人员在其报告中被识别,署名报告与文章一同发表),为研究与出版伦理、研究报告以及同行评审研究提供一个平台。随着该期刊进入第三年,我们回顾了期刊近期的事件和亮点,并探讨了期刊在同行评审中的性别和多样性方面的表现。我们还分享了主编们在同行评审模式、报告质量、出版过程中出现的常见研究诚信问题以及人们与已发表文献的互动方式等方面的特别关注。我们继续鼓励对同行评审、研究与出版伦理以及研究报告进行进一步研究,因为我们认为所有新举措都应以证据为基础。我们也随时愿意就该领域提供新解决方案的发展进行建设性讨论。