Jans Christoph, Sarno Eleonora, Collineau Lucie, Meile Leo, Stärk Katharina D C, Stephan Roger
Laboratory of Food Biotechnology, Institute of Food Nutrition and Health, Department of Health Science and Technology, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Institute for Food Safety and Hygiene, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Front Microbiol. 2018 Mar 6;9:362. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2018.00362. eCollection 2018.
Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) in bacteria is an increasing health concern. The spread of AMR bacteria (AMRB) between animals and humans via the food chain and the exchange of AMR genes requires holistic approaches for risk mitigation. The AMRB exposure of humans via food is currently only poorly understood leaving an important gap for intervention design. This study aimed to assess AMRB prevalence in retail food and subsequent exposure of Swiss consumers in a systematic literature review of data published between 1996 and 2016 covering the Swiss agriculture sector and relevant imported food. Data from 313 out of 9,473 collected studies were extracted yielding 122,438 food samples and 38,362 bacteria isolates of which 30,092 samples and 8,799 isolates were AMR positive. A median AMRB prevalence of >50% was observed for meat and seafood harboring , and spp. and to a lesser prevalence for milk products harboring starter culture bacteria. Gram-negative AMRB featured predominantly AMR against aminoglycosides, cephalosporins, fluoroquinolones, penicillins, sulfonamides, and tetracyclines observed at AMR exposures scores of levels 1 (medium) and 2 (high) for in meat as well as and in seafood. Gram-positive AMRB featured AMR against glycoproteins, lincosamides, macrolides and nitrofurans for and in meat sources, in seafood as well as and technologically important bacteria (incl. starters) in fermented or processed dairy products. Knowledge gaps were identified for AMR prevalence in dairy, plant, fermented meat and novel food products and for the role of specific indicator bacteria (), starter culture bacteria and their mobile genetic elements in AMR gene transfer. Raw meat, milk, seafood, and certain fermented dairy products featured a medium to high potential of AMR exposure for Gram-negative and Gram-positive foodborne pathogens and indicator bacteria. Food at retail, additional food categories including fermented and novel foods as well as technologically important bacteria and AMR genetics are recommended to be better integrated into systematic One Health AMR surveillance and mitigation strategies to close observed knowledge gaps and enable a comprehensive AMR risk assessment for consumers.
细菌中的抗菌药物耐药性(AMR)日益引起人们对健康的关注。耐药菌(AMRB)通过食物链在动物和人类之间传播以及耐药基因的交换,需要采取整体方法来降低风险。目前,人们对人类通过食物接触AMRB的情况了解甚少,这为干预措施的设计留下了重要空白。本研究旨在通过对1996年至2016年间发表的涵盖瑞士农业部门和相关进口食品的数据进行系统的文献综述,评估零售食品中AMRB的流行情况以及瑞士消费者随后的接触情况。从9473项收集的研究中提取了313项研究的数据,得到122438份食品样本和38362株细菌分离株,其中30092份样本和8799株分离株的AMR呈阳性。观察到携带 和 菌的肉类和海鲜的AMRB患病率中位数>50%,而携带发酵剂培养细菌的乳制品患病率较低。革兰氏阴性AMRB主要表现出对氨基糖苷类、头孢菌素类、氟喹诺酮类、青霉素类、磺胺类和四环素类的耐药性,在肉类中 以及海鲜中 和 的AMR暴露评分处于1级(中等)和2级(高)水平时观察到这种情况。革兰氏阳性AMRB对肉类来源的 、 ,海鲜中的 以及发酵或加工乳制品中的 和技术上重要的细菌(包括发酵剂)表现出对糖蛋白、林可酰胺类、大环内酯类和硝基呋喃类的耐药性。在乳制品、植物、发酵肉类和新型食品中的AMR流行情况以及特定指示菌( )、发酵剂培养细菌及其移动遗传元件在AMR基因转移中的作用方面发现了知识空白。生肉、牛奶、海鲜和某些发酵乳制品对革兰氏阴性和革兰氏阳性食源性病原体及指示菌具有中等至高的AMR暴露潜力。建议将零售食品、包括发酵食品和新型食品在内的其他食品类别以及技术上重要的细菌和AMR遗传学更好地纳入系统性的“同一健康”AMR监测和缓解策略中,以填补观察到的知识空白,并对消费者进行全面的AMR风险评估。