Innes Stanley I, Leboeuf-Yde Charlotte, Walker Bruce F
1School of Health Professions, Murdoch University, Murdoch, Australia.
Institut Franco-Européen de Chiropraxie, 94200 Ivry sur Seine, France.
Chiropr Man Therap. 2018 Mar 15;26:8. doi: 10.1186/s12998-018-0178-y. eCollection 2018.
Evidence suggests that a students' beliefs already prior to entering a program may be important as a determinant in sustaining unsuitable health care beliefs. Our objectives were to investigate the proportion of Australian chiropractic students who hold non-evidence-based beliefs in the first year of study and the extent to which they may be involved in non-musculoskeletal health conditions. Finally, to see if this proportion varies over the course of the chiropractic program.
In 2016, students from two Australian chiropractic programs answered a questionnaire on how often they would give advice on five common health conditions in their future practices as well as their opinion on whether chiropractic spinal adjustments could prevent or help seven health-related conditions.
From a possible 831 students, 444 responded (53%). Students were highly likely to offer advice (often/quite often) on a range of non-musculoskeletal conditions. The proportions were lowest in first year and highest the final year. Also, high numbers of students held non-evidence-based beliefs about 'chiropractic spinal adjustments' which tended to occur in gradually decreasing in numbers in sequential years, except for fifth year when a reversal of the pattern occurred.
New strategies are required for chiropractic educators if they are to produce graduates who understand and deliver evidence-based health care and able to be part of the mainstream health care system.
有证据表明,学生在进入某一专业课程之前的信念,可能是维持不适当的医疗保健信念的一个重要决定因素。我们的目标是调查在第一年学习时持有非循证信念的澳大利亚脊椎治疗专业学生的比例,以及他们可能参与非肌肉骨骼健康状况的程度。最后,观察这一比例在脊椎治疗专业课程过程中是否会发生变化。
2016年,来自澳大利亚两个脊椎治疗专业课程的学生回答了一份问卷,内容涉及他们在未来的实践中针对五种常见健康状况提供建议的频率,以及他们对脊椎推拿调整是否可以预防或帮助治疗七种与健康相关状况的看法。
在可能参与的831名学生中,444名做出了回应(53%)。学生们极有可能(经常/相当频繁地)就一系列非肌肉骨骼疾病提供建议。比例在第一年最低,最后一年最高。此外,大量学生对“脊椎推拿调整”持有非循证信念,这种信念的数量在连续几年中往往逐渐减少,除了第五年出现了模式逆转。
如果脊椎治疗教育工作者要培养出理解并提供循证医疗保健、能够成为主流医疗保健系统一部分的毕业生,就需要新的策略。