Kendre Pradip P, Jose Manoj P, Varghese Abraham M, Menon Jaideep C, Joseph Joseph K
Department of General Medicine, Little Flower Hospital and Research Centre, Angamaly, Kochi, Kerala 683572, India.
Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2018 Feb 1;112(2):88-93. doi: 10.1093/trstmh/try026.
Capillary leak syndrome (CLS) has been previously observed as a complication of Daboia russelii bite but not clearly defined or studied in length. This observational case-control study evaluates the mortality along with associated clinical and laboratory features.
Twenty-five patients who developed CLS were compared with 25 patients without CLS following Daboia russelii (Russell's viper) bite.
Development of CLS is associated with a significantly high risk of mortality; 11 (44%) patients with CLS died compared with 1 (4%) control (odds ratio 18.8 [95% confidence interval 2.2 to 161.99], p=0.002). Disease-defining manifestations included myalgia (22 [88%]), thirst (20 [80%]), parotid swelling (15 [60%]), conjunctival chemosis (19 [76%]) and hypotension (22 [88%]), which were unobserved in controls. Although several clinical and laboratory parameters were found to be predictive for development of CLS in univariate analysis, none of them had independent predictive value in multivariate analysis. Similarly, development of parotid swelling was the only factor with independent predictive value for mortality in multivariate analysis. Even though the number of vials of snake antivenom used is more in CLS, it seems unlikely to improve the mortality in CLS.
This study proves that CLS is a well-defined complication of Russell's viper bite with high mortality but with clear predictors for the development of CLS and mortality.
毛细血管渗漏综合征(CLS)先前已被观察到是罗素蝰蛇咬伤的一种并发症,但尚未得到明确界定或深入研究。这项观察性病例对照研究评估了死亡率以及相关的临床和实验室特征。
将25例发生CLS的患者与25例罗素蝰蛇咬伤后未发生CLS的患者进行比较。
CLS的发生与显著高的死亡风险相关;11例(44%)CLS患者死亡,而对照组为1例(4%)(比值比18.8[95%置信区间2.2至161.99],p = 0.002)。疾病的典型表现包括肌痛(22例[88%])、口渴(20例[80%])、腮腺肿大(15例[60%])、结膜水肿(19例[76%])和低血压(22例[88%]),对照组未观察到这些表现。虽然在单因素分析中发现几个临床和实验室参数可预测CLS的发生,但在多因素分析中它们均无独立预测价值。同样,在多因素分析中,腮腺肿大的发生是唯一对死亡率有独立预测价值的因素。尽管CLS患者使用的抗蛇毒血清瓶数更多,但似乎不太可能改善CLS患者的死亡率。
本研究证明,CLS是罗素蝰蛇咬伤一种明确界定的并发症,死亡率高,但有CLS发生和死亡的明确预测因素。