Paton Carol, Cookson John, Ferrier I Nicol, Bhatti Sumera, Fagan Elizabeth, Barnes Thomas R E
Prescribing Observatory for Mental Health (POMH-UK), Royal College of Psychiatrists, London, UK.
The Centre for Psychiatry, Imperial College London, London, UK.
BMJ Open. 2018 Apr 12;8(4):e020450. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-020450.
To review prescribing practice concerning valproate, an established human teratogen, for the management of bipolar disorder in women of childbearing age.
The Prescribing Observatory for Mental Health conducted a baseline clinical audit in the UK, as part of a quality improvement programme.
Six hundred and forty-eight clinical teams from 55 mental health Trusts submitted retrospective treatment data relating to patients with a diagnosis of bipolar disorder.
Of the audit sample of 6705 patients, 3854 were 50 years of age or younger. Valproate was prescribed for 24% of women and 43% men in this age group, and the mean dose of valproate was lower in women (1196 mg) than in men (1391 mg). For only half of such women was there documented evidence that information had been provided on the risks for the unborn child and the need for adequate contraception. Valproate was more often used in men to treat mania and aggression, while the most common treatment targets in women were hypomania and relapse prevention.
Despite explicit recommendations in national treatment guidelines and published safety alerts and warnings regarding the use of valproate in women of childbearing age, current prescribing of this medication to such women in the context of the treatment of bipolar disorder falls short of best practice, particularly with regard to provision of information regarding the risks associated with exposure to valproate during pregnancy. While women younger than 50 years of age were less likely to be prescribed valproate than men in the same age group, and at a lower dosage, it is unclear to what extent this reflects clinicians' concerns about teratogenicity or is driven by perceptions of the indication for valproate, and the dosage required, for the treatment of different phases of the disorder in men and women.
回顾有关丙戊酸盐(一种已明确的人类致畸剂)用于育龄期女性双相情感障碍治疗的处方实践。
作为一项质量改进计划的一部分,心理健康处方观察站在英国进行了一项基线临床审计。
来自55个精神健康信托机构的648个临床团队提交了与双相情感障碍诊断患者相关的回顾性治疗数据。
在6705名患者的审计样本中,3854名年龄在50岁及以下。该年龄组中,24%的女性和43%的男性使用了丙戊酸盐,女性丙戊酸盐的平均剂量(1196毫克)低于男性(1391毫克)。只有一半的此类女性有记录证据表明已被告知未出生胎儿的风险以及采取充分避孕措施的必要性。丙戊酸盐在男性中更常用于治疗躁狂和攻击行为,而女性中最常见的治疗目标是轻躁狂和预防复发。
尽管国家治疗指南中有明确建议,且已发布有关丙戊酸盐在育龄期女性中使用的安全警报和警告,但目前在双相情感障碍治疗中给此类女性开具这种药物的处方未达最佳实践,特别是在提供有关孕期接触丙戊酸盐相关风险的信息方面。虽然50岁以下的女性比同年龄组的男性开具丙戊酸盐的可能性更小,且剂量更低,但尚不清楚这在多大程度上反映了临床医生对致畸性的担忧,还是由对丙戊酸盐治疗男性和女性疾病不同阶段的适应症及所需剂量的认知所驱动。