University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Polytechnique Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
PLoS One. 2018 Apr 17;13(4):e0195733. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0195733. eCollection 2018.
Patients with mild degenerative cervical myelopathy (DCM) are often managed non-operatively, and surgery is recommended if neurological progression occurs. However, detection of progression is often subjective. Quantitative MRI (qMRI) directly measures spinal cord (SC) tissue changes, detecting axonal injury, demyelination, and atrophy. This longitudinal study compared multiparametric qMRI with clinical measures of progression in non-operative DCM patients.
26 DCM patients were followed. Clinical data included modified Japanese Orthopedic Association (mJOA) and additional assessments. 3T qMRI data included cross sectional area, diffusion fractional anisotropy, magnetization transfer ratio, and T2*-weighted white/grey matter signal ratio, extracted from the compressed SC and above/below. Progression was defined as 1) patients' subjective impression, 2) 2-point mJOA decrease, 3) ≥3 clinical measures worsening ≥5%, 4) increased compression on MRI, or 5) ≥1 of 10 qMRI measures or composite score worsening (p < 0.004, corrected).
Follow-up (13.5 ± 4.9 months) included mJOA in all 26 patients, MRI in 25, and clinical/qMRI in 22. 42.3% reported subjective worsening, compared with mJOA (11.5%), MRI (20%), comprehensive assessments (54.6%), and qMRI (68.2%). Relative to subjective worsening, qMRI showed 100% sensitivity and 53.3% specificity compared with comprehensive assessments (75%, 60%), mJOA (27.3%, 100%), and MRI (18.2%, 81.3%). A decision-making algorithm incorporating qMRI identified progression and recommended surgery for 11 subjects (42.3%).
Quantitative MRI shows high sensitivity to detect myelopathic progression. Our results suggest that neuroplasticity and behavioural adaptation may mask progressive SC tissue injury. qMRI appears to be a useful method to confirm subtle myelopathic progression in individual patients, representing an advance toward clinical translation of qMRI.
轻度退变性颈髓病(DCM)患者通常采用非手术治疗,如果出现神经功能进展则推荐手术。然而,进展的检测通常是主观的。定量 MRI(qMRI)可直接测量脊髓(SC)组织变化,检测轴突损伤、脱髓鞘和萎缩。本纵向研究比较了多参数 qMRI 与非手术 DCM 患者的临床进展评估。
对 26 例 DCM 患者进行随访。临床资料包括改良日本骨科协会(mJOA)评分和其他评估。3T qMRI 数据包括从受压 SC 及上下提取的横截面积、扩散分数各向异性、磁化传递率和 T2*-加权白/灰质信号比。进展定义为 1)患者主观感觉,2)mJOA 评分下降 2 分,3)≥3 项临床评估恶化≥5%,4)MRI 显示受压增加,或 5)≥10 项 qMRI 测量值或综合评分恶化(p<0.004,校正)。
26 例患者均完成随访(13.5±4.9 个月),其中 mJOA 评估 26 例,MRI 评估 25 例,临床/qMRI 评估 22 例。与 mJOA(11.5%)、MRI(20%)、综合评估(54.6%)和 qMRI(68.2%)相比,42.3%报告主观恶化。与主观恶化相比,qMRI 对综合评估(75%,60%)、mJOA(27.3%,100%)和 MRI(18.2%,81.3%)的灵敏度为 100%,特异度为 53.3%。纳入 qMRI 的决策算法可识别进展,并建议 11 例患者(42.3%)手术。
定量 MRI 对检测脊髓病进展具有高灵敏度。我们的结果表明,神经可塑性和行为适应可能掩盖进行性 SC 组织损伤。qMRI 似乎是一种有用的方法,可确认个体患者的细微脊髓病进展,代表了 qMRI 向临床转化的进展。