Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering, Penn State University, State College, Pennsylvania 16801, USA.
Center for Turbulence Research, Stanford University, Stanford, California, 94305 USA.
Phys Rev E. 2018 May;97(5-1):053110. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevE.97.053110.
Fluid motions in the inertial range of isotropic turbulence are fractal, with their space-filling capacity slightly below regular three-dimensional objects, which is a consequence of the energy cascade. Besides the energy cascade, the other often encountered cascading process is the momentum cascade in wall-bounded flows. Despite the long-existing analogy between the two processes, many of the thoroughly investigated aspects of the energy cascade have so far received little attention in studies of the momentum counterpart, e.g., the possibility of the momentum-transferring scales in the logarithmic region being fractal has not been considered. In this work, this possibility is pursued, and we discuss one of its implications. Following the same dimensional arguments that lead to the D=2.33 fractal dimension of wrinkled surfaces in isotropic turbulence, we show that the large-scale momentum-carrying eddies may also be fractal and non-space-filling, which then leads to the power-law scaling of the mean velocity profile. The logarithmic law of the wall, on the other hand, corresponds to space-filling eddies, as suggested by Townsend [The Structure of Turbulent Shear Flow (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1980)]. Because the space-filling capacity is an integral geometric quantity, the analysis presented in this work provides us with a low-order quantity, with which, one would be able to distinguish between the logarithmic law and the power law.
各向同性湍流惯性区内的流体运动具有分形特征,其空间填充能力略低于规则的三维物体,这是能量级联的结果。除了能量级联之外,另一个经常遇到的级联过程是壁面限制流中的动量级联。尽管这两个过程之间存在长期存在的类比,但迄今为止,能量级联的许多经过深入研究的方面在动量级联的研究中很少受到关注,例如,在对数区中传递动量的尺度可能具有分形的可能性尚未得到考虑。在这项工作中,我们探讨了这种可能性,并讨论了其中的一个含义。根据导致各向同性湍流中褶皱表面 D=2.33 分形维数的相同维度论证,我们表明,大尺度的动量携带涡旋也可能是分形的且非空间填充的,这进而导致平均速度分布呈幂律。另一方面,壁面定律对应于空间填充的涡旋,正如汤森 [《湍流剪切流的结构》(剑桥大学出版社,剑桥,1980 年)] 所建议的那样。由于空间填充能力是一个整体的几何量,因此本文中的分析为我们提供了一个低阶的量,通过这个量,我们可以区分对数律和幂律。