Motley Robert O, Joe Sean
Doctoral student at the Washington University in Saint Louis Brown School of Social Work.
Professor at the Washington University in Saint Louis Brown School of Social Work.
J Soc Social Work Res. 2018 Spring;9(1):49-67. doi: 10.1086/696355. Epub 2018 Jan 31.
Disparities in police responses to Black and White people have received significant research and public attention in recent years. This study examines self-reported accounts of exposure to and perceptions of police use of force among Black and White ethnic groups by sex and income level.
Using bivariate and multivariate approaches, we analyzed data from the Bureau of Justice Statistics 2011 Police-Public Contact Survey, a measure administered to a nationally representative sample of U.S. residents. Participants were asked a series of questions about their most recent contact with police during a 12-month period. Our analyses were limited to Black ( = 59; mean age 28.8 years) and White ( = 366; mean age 34.6 years) participants whose most recent involuntary contact with police included a street stop.
For Black residents, being male and having an income under $20,000 significantly increased the risk for exposure to police use of force during a street stop. For White residents, being male, having an income under $20,000, or being age 35 or older significantly increased the risk for exposure to police use of force during a street stop.
Future research will benefit from additional attention to the cumulative impact of police use of force and how experience with police use of force shapes U.S. residents' understanding of and expectations for procedural justice.
近年来,警察对黑人和白人的反应差异受到了大量研究和公众关注。本研究按性别和收入水平,考察了黑人和白人族群中自我报告的警察使用武力的经历及看法。
我们采用双变量和多变量方法,分析了美国司法统计局2011年警察与公众接触调查的数据,该调查对具有全国代表性的美国居民样本进行。参与者被问及一系列关于他们在12个月期间最近一次与警察接触的问题。我们的分析仅限于最近一次非自愿与警察接触包括街头拦截的黑人(n = 59;平均年龄28.8岁)和白人(n = 366;平均年龄34.6岁)参与者。
对于黑人居民,男性且收入低于20,000美元会显著增加在街头拦截期间遭遇警察使用武力的风险。对于白人居民,男性、收入低于20,000美元或年龄在35岁及以上会显著增加在街头拦截期间遭遇警察使用武力的风险。
未来的研究将受益于对警察使用武力的累积影响以及警察使用武力的经历如何塑造美国居民对程序正义的理解和期望给予更多关注。