Akhtar Saeed College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Lahore, Pakistan.
Department of Pharmacy, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur Bahawalpur, Punjab, Pakistan.
PLoS One. 2018 Jun 27;13(6):e0199456. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0199456. eCollection 2018.
Adverse drug events (ADEs) are the fifth leading cause of death and thus responsible for a large number of hospital admissions in all over the globe. This study was aimed to assess the antibiotics associated preventability of ADEs and causality of adverse drug reactions (ADRs) among hospitalized patients.
A prospective, cross-sectional, observational study was conducted in four tertiary care public sector hospitals of Lahore, Pakistan. Study population consisted of hospitalized patients who were prescribed with one or more antibiotics. Data were collected between 1st January, 2017 and 31st June, 2017 from 1,249 patients (384 patients aged ≤ 18 years and 865 patients aged >18 years). Schumock and Thornton scale was used to assess the preventability of the ADEs. Medication errors (MEs) that caused preventable ADEs were assessed by MEs tracking form while Naranjo score was used to evaluate the causal relation of ADRs with the antibiotics. Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 21.0. Armonk, NY: IBM Corp.) and Microsoft Excel (MS Office, 2010) were used for data analysis.
2,686 antibiotics were prescribed to 1,249 patients. Among them, fluoroquinolones (11.8%), macrolides (11.6%) and cephalosporins (10.9%) were the most frequently prescribed antibiotics. The most affected organ system by antibiotics associated ADEs was gastrointestinal tract. A total of 486 ADEs were found. The preventability assessment revealed that most of the ADEs (58.4%) were preventable (43.6% of the ADEs were definitely preventable while 14.8% were probably preventable) and caused by MEs including wrong drug (40.1%) and monitoring errors (25.0%), during the stage of physician ordering (22.2%) and patient monitoring (21.1%). The errors were caused due to non-adherence of policies (38.4%) and lack of information about antibiotics (32%). Most of the non-preventable ADEs or ADRs among adults and children were "probable" (35.5%) and "possible" (35.8%), respectively. Logistic regression analysis revealed that ADEs were significantly less among females (OR = 0.047, 95%CI = 0.018-0.121, p-value = <0.001), patients aged 18-52 years (OR = 0.041, 95%CI = 0.013-0.130, p-value = <0.001), tuberculosis patients (OR = 0.304, 95%CI = 0.186-0.497, p-value = <0.001), patients with acute respiratory tract infections (OR = 0.004, 95%CI = 0.01-0.019, p-value = <0.001) and among the patients prescribed with 2 antibiotics per prescription (OR = 0.455, 95%CI = 0.319-0.650, p-value = <0.001).
According to preventability assessment most of the ADEs were definitely preventable and caused by MEs due to non-adherence of policies and lack of information about antibiotics. The causality assessment of non-preventable ADEs showed that most of the ADRs were probable and possible.
药物不良反应(ADE)是全球第五大死亡原因,因此导致大量患者住院。本研究旨在评估住院患者中与抗生素相关的 ADE 可预防率和药物不良反应(ADR)的因果关系。
本前瞻性、横断面、观察性研究在巴基斯坦拉合尔的四家三级公立医院进行。研究人群包括接受一种或多种抗生素治疗的住院患者。数据于 2017 年 1 月 1 日至 2017 年 6 月 31 日期间从 1249 名患者(≤18 岁的患者 384 名,>18 岁的患者 865 名)中收集。采用 Schumock 和 Thornton 量表评估 ADE 的可预防率。通过药物错误(ME)跟踪表评估导致可预防 ADE 的 ME,使用 Naranjo 评分评估 ADR 与抗生素的因果关系。使用社会科学统计软件包(IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows,版本 21.0,纽约州阿蒙克:IBM 公司)和 Microsoft Excel(MS Office,2010)进行数据分析。
1249 名患者共开出 2686 种抗生素。其中,氟喹诺酮类(11.8%)、大环内酯类(11.6%)和头孢菌素类(10.9%)是最常开的抗生素。抗生素相关 ADE 最易影响的器官系统是胃肠道。共发现 486 例 ADE。预防评估显示,大多数 ADE(58.4%)是可预防的(43.6%的 ADE 是肯定可预防的,14.8%是可能可预防的),由 ME 引起,包括用药错误(40.1%)和监测错误(25.0%),发生在医生开处方阶段(22.2%)和患者监测阶段(21.1%)。这些错误是由于不遵守政策(38.4%)和缺乏抗生素信息(32%)造成的。成人和儿童中不可预防的 ADE 或 ADR 大多数是“可能”(35.5%)和“很可能”(35.8%)。Logistic 回归分析显示,女性(OR=0.047,95%CI=0.018-0.121,p 值<0.001)、18-52 岁的患者(OR=0.041,95%CI=0.013-0.130,p 值<0.001)、肺结核患者(OR=0.304,95%CI=0.186-0.497,p 值<0.001)、急性呼吸道感染患者(OR=0.004,95%CI=0.01-0.019,p 值<0.001)和每处方开 2 种抗生素的患者(OR=0.455,95%CI=0.319-0.650,p 值<0.001)的 ADE 发生率较低。
根据预防评估,大多数 ADE 是肯定可预防的,由 ME 引起,原因是不遵守政策和缺乏抗生素信息。不可预防的 ADE 的因果关系评估显示,大多数 ADR 是可能和很可能的。