Al-Ekrish Asma'a A, Widmann Gerlig, Alfadda Sara A
Int J Prosthodont. 2018 Jul/Aug;31(4):342-345. doi: 10.11607/ijp.5714.
To propose a revised Lekholm and Zarb classification that takes into account all possible combinations of compact and trabecular bone and to provide guidelines for increased reproducibility of the classification.
Three new classes were added to the previous classification. The new classes have been designated as subclasses of bone types 2 and 3, as follows: Type 2b: Thick layer of compact bone surrounding a core of medium-density trabecular bone; Type 2c: Thick layer of compact bone surrounding a core of low-density trabecular bone; and Type 3b: Thin layer of compact bone surrounding a core of medium-density trabecular bone. Three interpretation guidelines were recommended to increase the reproducibility of the revised classification. Three experienced examiners were trained using the revised classification and provided with computed tomography (CT) sectional images of edentulous jawbones for classification. Each examiner classified the images twice with at least a 1-week interval. The intra-observer agreement was measured.
The kappa statistic for the intra-observer agreement of the examiners ranged from 0.835 to 0.919 (P < .001).
The high reproducibility of the proposed revised CT-based Lekholm and Zarb classification obtained in the current study suggests its efficacy in distinguishing between the various combinations of compact and trabecular bone.
提出一种修订后的莱克霍尔姆和扎尔布分类法,该分类法考虑了密质骨和松质骨的所有可能组合,并为提高该分类法的可重复性提供指导原则。
在先前的分类法中增加了三个新类别。这些新类别被指定为骨类型2和3的子类,具体如下:2b型:厚层密质骨围绕中等密度的松质骨核心;2c型:厚层密质骨围绕低密度的松质骨核心;3b型:薄层密质骨围绕中等密度的松质骨核心。推荐了三条解读指南以提高修订后分类法的可重复性。对三名经验丰富的检查人员进行了使用修订后分类法的培训,并为他们提供了无牙颌骨的计算机断层扫描(CT)断层图像以进行分类。每位检查人员对图像进行两次分类,间隔至少1周。测量了观察者内一致性。
检查人员的观察者内一致性的kappa统计量范围为0.835至0.919(P <.001)。
在本研究中获得的基于CT的修订后的莱克霍尔姆和扎尔布分类法具有较高的可重复性,表明其在区分密质骨和松质骨的各种组合方面的有效性。