Laungani Ramesh, Tanner Colby, Brooks Tessa Durham, Clement Barbara, Clouse Melissa, Doyle Erin, Dworak Scott, Elder Brad, Marley Kate, Schofield Brett
Biology Department, Doane University, Crete, NE 68333.
Department of Biological Sciences, Misericordia University, Dallas, PA 18612.
J Microbiol Biol Educ. 2018 Jun 29;19(2). doi: 10.1128/jmbe.v19i2.1517. eCollection 2018.
Reports such as call for integration of course-based undergraduate research experiences (CUREs) into biology curricula and less emphasis on "cookbook" laboratories. CUREs, often characterized by a single open-ended research question, allow students to develop hypotheses, design experiments, and collaborate with peers. Conversely, "cookbook" labs incentivize task completion and have pre-determined experimental outcomes. While research comparing CUREs and "cookbook" labs is growing, there are fewer comparisons among CUREs. Here, we present a novel CURE built around an invasive grass, . We evaluated this CURE's effectiveness in improving students' understanding of the competency relating to the application of the scientific process through development and testing of hypotheses. We did so by comparing changes in pre- and posttest scores on the Experimental Design Ability Test (EDAT) between Brome CURE students and students in a concurrent CURE, SEA-PHAGES. While students in both CUREs showed improvements at the end of the semester, Brome CURE students showed a greater increase in EDAT scores than did SEA-PHAGES CURE students. Additionally, Brome CURE students had significantly higher gains in 6 of the 10 EDAT criteria. We conclude that the Brome CURE is an effective ecological parallel to the SEA-PHAGES CURE and can help students gain a meaningful understanding of competencies. Journal of Microbiology & Biology Education.
诸如这样的报告呼吁将基于课程的本科研究经历(CUREs)融入生物学课程,并减少对“食谱式”实验室的重视。CUREs通常以一个开放式研究问题为特征,让学生能够提出假设、设计实验并与同伴合作。相反,“食谱式”实验室鼓励完成任务,且有预先确定的实验结果。虽然比较CUREs和“食谱式”实验室的研究在不断增加,但对CUREs之间的比较却较少。在此,我们展示了一个围绕一种入侵性禾本科植物构建的新型CURE。我们通过假设的提出和检验,评估了这个CURE在提高学生对与科学过程应用相关能力的理解方面的有效性。我们通过比较Brome CURE课程的学生与同期进行的CURE课程SEA - PHAGES的学生在实验设计能力测试(EDAT)前后测分数的变化来做到这一点。虽然两个CURE课程的学生在学期末都有进步,但Brome CURE课程的学生在EDAT分数上的提高比SEA - PHAGES CURE课程的学生更大。此外,在EDAT的10项标准中,Brome CURE课程的学生在6项标准上有显著更高的提升。我们得出结论,Brome CURE是与SEA - PHAGES CURE等效的有效生态学课程,并且可以帮助学生对相关能力有有意义的理解。《微生物学与生物学教育杂志》